Chomsky then elaborated on the idea of social security and identification systems like the one in the US, and said, “Then comes the question of how it is used. Whether in an abusive way to control people or if it is used to facilitate people’s everyday lives, to improve things they can do, to make things easier for them and more convenient and so on. So those are the two questions that have to be raised. In the case of the Indian system, which I have not investigated, but by what you describe, it seems abusive in both respects, both in how it was instituted and how it is used.”