An Attack in 2007

  • Thread starter Thread starter blr_p
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 16
  • Views Views 2,835
I flew to New Delhi after my stay in Pakistan and met with two senior officials from the Research and Analysis Wing, India’s national intelligence agency. (Of course, as in Pakistan, no allegation about the other side should be taken at face value.) “Our worries are about the nuclear weapons in Pakistan,” one of the officials said. “Not because we are worried about the mullahs taking over the country; we’re worried about those senior officers in the Pakistan Army who are Caliphates”—believers in a fundamentalist pan-Islamic state. “We know some of them and we have names,” he said. “We’ve been watching colonels who are now brigadiers. These are the guys who could blackmail the whole world”—that is, by seizing a nuclear weapon.

The Indian intelligence official went on, “Do we know if the Americans have that intelligence? This is not in the scheme of the way you Americans look at things—‘Kayani is a great guy! Let’s have a drink and smoke a cigar with him and his buddies.’ Some of the men we are watching have notions of leading an Islamic army.”

In an interview the next afternoon, an Indian official who has dealt diplomatically with Pakistan for years said, “Pakistan is in trouble, and it’s worrisome to us because an unstable Pakistan is the worst thing we can have.” But he wasn’t sure what America could do. “They like us better in Pakistan than you Americans,” he said. “I can tell you that in a public-opinion poll we, India, will beat you.”


Source

thought that jaswants singh's book was just a psy ops but it was more than that.
Care to expand on this statement ?
 
“Pakistan is in trouble, and it’s worrisome to us because an unstable Pakistan is the worst thing we can have.”


other than nukes, i would say a disintegrated Pakistan is in India's interest, For example, it would free up the Indian army to face the chinese and it would establish India as the sole power in south asia.
 
Well, after disintegration, lets say they fight among themselves, and nuke each other. India can help, by selling weapons to everyone just like what the US, UK & Russia have been doing since our independence. I guess, its too much optimism on my part.:thumbsup:
 
Not optimism but naivete.Pakistan is not going to disintegrate. If you notice they are slowly moving in and cleaning up the troubled areas, Swat, NWFP etc. That means estabilshing the GoP's writ in these troubled areas. Once thats done they'll move into other areas.Cpl years from now and with the Yanks slowly withdrawing from Afghanistan, things will be well on their way to recovery.If it helps, and wrt to India, don't think of Pakistan on its own, think of it as a part of China and China won't let them fall apart :)
 
But you cannot seperate distintegrated from nukes can you ?

I can't, but the Americans can.

I guess, its too much optimism on my part.
Optimism is always a good thing :thumbsup:

Pakistan is not going to disintegrate.
Now, that's too pessimistic :D (or optimistic, depending on your PoV)

If you notice they are slowly moving in and cleaning up the troubled areas, Swat, NWFP etc. That means estabilshing the GoP's writ in these troubled areas. Once thats done they'll move into other areas.

Imho, the belief that after clearing NWFP, they would take care of militants in Punjab (who are targeting India) is just wishful thinking. Pakistani military considers them assets and they would never go against these militants.
 
I can't, but the Americans can.
How so ?


Now, that's too pessimistic :D (or optimistic, depending on your PoV)

I'll settle for realistic :)



Imho, the belief that after clearing NWFP, they would take care of militants in Punjab (who are targeting India) is just wishful thinking. Pakistani military considers them assets and they would never go against these militants.
Of course, i was referring only to the militants causing problems for the Paks. Since these are the types one is given to believe, will be responsible for disintegration of Pak. If those militants are neutralised then there is no disintegration.

SO it all revolves round whether the Paks are capable of doing so. Depending on who you ask its either yes or no, i chose yes.
 
Back