LCO refusing to bind ONU unless I take 3/6 month prepaid plan

  • Thread starter Thread starter Sanemi
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 14
  • Views Views 213
Messages
240
Location
India
ISP
BSNL | KV | Asianet
I wanted to share an experience I had today with my local LCO and get some opinions from others here.

I use two prepaid broadband connections that were earlier provided by the same LCO on two separate ONUs/ONTs. Since both are prepaid connections and not postpaid, I usually recharge whichever one I want to use depending on the service quality and my requirement at that time. I had already informed the LCO multiple times not to unbind either ONU because of this arrangement, and he had acknowledged it earlier as well.

Before recharging any connection, I normally check whether the ONU is still properly registered/binded. Today when I checked, I found that two ONU had been unbinded again.

I tried calling the LCO several times. As usual, there was no response initially. After repeated calls, he finally answered. I politely explained that the ONU was unbinded and requested him to bind it again so I could recharge and continue using the connection.

But instead of helping, he told me that since I am “not an active customer,” he will only bind the ONU if I recharge a 3-month or 6-month prepaid plan. I told him clearly that I only prefer monthly plans because I previously had a very bad experience after taking a long-term broadband plan where support and NOC response were extremely poor.

What disappointed me more was that he started explaining that he only gets around ₹150 commission per customer, whereas from what I understand, the normal LCO commission structure here is around 60% of the plan value.


Honestly, I don’t understand why a prepaid customer should be forced into long-term plans just to keep the ONU bind and usable. If the connection is prepaid, shouldn’t the customer have the freedom to recharge monthly whenever needed?



Has anyone else faced similar behaviour from their LCO? Is intentionally unbinding an ONU to pressure customers into longer recharges considered acceptable practice?
 
It looks like he's just tired of your antics. You are not a paying customer, and I see no point why he should keep your ONU bonded to his OLT or entertain you at all. While not a small number, OLTs still do have a limit to the number of ONUs that can be registered, which for non-paying customers is wasted resources. And no one is getting the 60% commission; it usually is 25-50%. They get a higher commission if a customer buys a longer term, which explains their likeliness to ask you to buy a 3/6-month plan. So 150 INR for an approx. 500 INR plan (before tax) is an accurate number.
 
I support the LCO's decision. Even if he is getting 60% commission why should It bother you?
Do you know how much of that commission goes towards maintaining infrastructure, Keeping local staffs to do the end mile connectivity and maintaining it, running an office with staffs, navigating through local politics aka pole rights.
 
50% is the LCO commission + ~80% of the ONT value. BSNL no longer gives out prepaid connections. I also agree with @Blue Leaf, while fiber cabling is not that expensive per meter for indoor use outdoor rated cabling is very expensive especially when cable cuts are the LCO's problem + equipment and labour. The cable cutting nonsense by power grid people was very expensive.

Also @Lolita_Magnum is correct, OLTs are expensive for the amount of horsepower they carry (very little, sometimes less than an ONT since they just have to auth and manage vlans) so there are limits to how many ONTs can be bound.
 
See usually this isn’t a problem for the LCO. Bind/unbind - he doesn’t care. Once the fiber is pulled and you’ve paid for the labour and materials, it’s really no bother keeping everything as is. But my best guess is, your LCO has expanded and is beginning to hit the upper limit of the number of ONTs supported per OLT port. So now his paying customers will take priority. Secondly you being on a prepaid plan is hurting his margins. Postpaid would have given him some more security in terms of revenue flows. The only way I see you continuing your ‘privilege’ is to pay a monthly rental directly to the LCO. Another would be to bind just one ONT, and keep WANs separated through VLANs. Just set up your own router downstream of the single ONT, send the WAN connections as VLAN tagged between the router and ONT.
 
@pillaicha while that's a good idea, BSNL cannot legally allow that to work or bind macs for routers that were not provided by them anymore (unless biz plans)
 
60% is standard if lco negotiates well then can secure a deal upto 70%. But I think there is a possibility that your dumb ont is registered with this connection because at smaller isps authentication only happens at BNG and smaller ISPs just allow all olt to register ont by default and bridge mode generally passes through
 
Back