Red Terror!

  • Thread starter Thread starter SVK
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 26
  • Views Views 5,547
I think the debate about whether Naxals are terrorist or not is already over, some people may still deny it but I believe the rest of India has already decided that they are terrorist.About what to do against them, I think the SPOs should be used in a much larger number and they should be given better training to fight the Naxals. SPOs are mostly tribals themselves and they would have a far better understanding of the terrain than the CRPF guys. who are brought in from across the country.about AizwaLAs horrible as it is, the bombing sent a clear message to Manipur separatist and to other groups in the NE that breaking away from the union is not a possibility. Having said that, I also believe how the Indian state treats the people from NE is a disgrace.
 
About what to do against them, I think the SPOs should be used in a much larger number and they should be given better training to fight the Naxals. SPOs are mostly tribals themselves and they would have a far better understanding of the terrain than the CRPF guys. who are brought in from across the country.

So are most of the naxals . How willing will they be to launch a large offensive against their own people .
 
about AizwaL
As horrible as it is, the bombing sent a clear message to Manipur separatist and to other groups in the NE that breaking away from the union is not a possibility. Having said that, I also believe how the Indian state treats the people from NE is a disgrace.

yeah tyrant tell me which representative democracy govt has done this to its own people.

indira gandhi was a tyrant.it was during her administration this was done and not to mention the emergency.all this separatist problem can be solved if you have federalism like in usa where states create the centre but we want more centralization.

your reply is just like stalin,mao,hitler.

whatever is happening to this country is what we deserve.the politicians buy votes and for 5 yr fill thier coffers.

i wont be surprised that by 2050 india doesn't exist and there are separate countries in india.

have you ever though that naxalism would be over if we reinstate right to private property?,give the mine royalties to the affected?.

no you advocate bombing our own people which only evil,inhumane,devilish person can you do and you are one.
 
I think the debate about whether Naxals are terrorist or not is already over, some people may still deny it but I believe the rest of India has already decided that they are terrorist.
Wrong, they are insurgents that may at times use terrorist tactics.

Anytime i read in the media someone referring to them as terrorists, i know the person is ignorant of the topic. If one is unable to accurately even define the opponent then how much credibility does whatever they say next have ;)

SPOs are mostly tribals themselves and they would have a far better understanding of the terrain than the CRPF guys.
And thats what they already did in Chhattisgarh, they known as the Salwah Judum. You want to tell me how well that went ? An absolute disaster in that it compounded the problem.

I'm still of the opinion the Andhras have a viable model here, they copied the Punjabi's. So we have two instances were it has worked. But there have to be land reforms at the end of this 'cleanup' or the problem will come back in the future and be more troublesome.

If you get a chance google up what KPS Gill has to say on the matter, same magazine, very enlightening read. Ties up very well with what Rammohan says, ie a lack of leadership. Those with experience in this field from what i've read have no confusion wrt to the topic, and instead its actually the public that is confused about this topic, some will call them patriots when they're not or terrorists ;)
 
So are most of the naxals . How willing will they be to launch a large offensive against their own people .

SPOs and Naxals have been at loggerheads for a long time, remember the recent attack on a bus carrying policemen, they were all SPOs. Naxals target SPOs with a vengeance since they are more effective in their fight against Naxals.

Wrong, they are insurgents that may at times use terrorist tactics.

:huh:

Any person/group that uses terror tactics is a terrorist.

Your argument is like saying, 'I may kill people sometime, but I am not a killer'.

Anytime i read in the media someone referring to them as terrorists, i know the person is ignorant of the topic. If one is unable to accurately even define the opponent then how much credibility does whatever they say next have ;)

Anytime i read in the media someone referring to them as Insurgents, I know the person is a starry eyed leftist ;), who hasn't realized how much the Naxal movement has changed since its beginning. It may have started out as an insurgency but its no longer one.

And thats what they already did in Chhattisgarh, they known as the Salwah Judum. You want to tell me how well that went ? An absolute disaster in that it compounded the problem.

There is a huge difference between Salwa Judum and SPOs. SJ is a private milita, that operated on its own. while I believe SPO come under the command of the state police. State command and control can make sure no atrocities are committed by SJ, while the Tribal nature of the group can give them an advantage when fighting in the jungle.

I'm still of the opinion the Andhras have a viable model here, they copied the Punjabi's. So we have two instances were it has worked. But there have to be land reforms at the end of this 'cleanup' or the problem will come back in the future and be more troublesome.


I am sure you know whatever happened in Punjab to put down an insurgency wasn't squeaky clean either.
 
:huh:

Any person/group that uses terror tactics is a terrorist.
This definition is too simple to be taken seriously

Your argument is like saying, 'I may kill people sometime, but I am not a killer'.
I never said that.

Anytime i read in the media someone referring to them as Insurgents, I know the person is a starry eyed leftist ;), who hasn't realized how much the Naxal movement has changed since its beginning. It may have started out as an insurgency but its no longer one.
Haha, maybe you should broaden your reading a bit, i like to get views from all sides of the spectrum. If per you the lefties don't know what the naxals are then the right wingers sure as hell will not. The performance in BJP ruled states is ample evidence of that fact.

And the distinction is paramount because it dictates the response and eventual solution. Get the definitions muddled up and you shoot yourself in the foot!

So tell us all what have the naxals become now ?

Tell us the difference between a terrorist & an insurgent.

If you like i'll agree to the term extremist but thats an overly broad term and rather useless in terms of how to tackle it.

There is a huge difference between Salwa Judum and SPOs. SJ is a private milita, that operated on its own. while I believe SPO come under the command of the state police. State command and control can make sure no atrocities are committed by SJ, while the Tribal nature of the group can give them an advantage when fighting in the jungle.
But they had the state's support & protection nevertheless. SJ was the state where the state did not want to go. It's clear now this is not the kind of SPO you have in mind.

The SPO's you talk about are more in Andhra. But you know what, being a tribal and knowing the place helps but winning the confidence of the ppl is even better because thats where the best intel comes from. And that confidence is not going to come easily unless the state tidies up its image and gets serious about dealing with this.

Otherwise SPO's on their own and in more numbers, alone, won't make much difference.


I am sure you know whatever happened in Punjab to put down an insurgency wasn't squeaky clean either.
Sure and i accept that with a great deal of difficulty but a insurgent war is a very long drawn dirty affair. The kind of stuff that makes warthog's blood boil :) The difference, at times, between good guy & bad guy is almost non-existant, the end goal however is.

The reason i've advocated this is because i do not believe in cutting deals with naxals. Naxals are not the representatives of the tribals, they are just middlemen and have completely replaced at gunpoint the non-existant state in the areas concerned.

The naxals need to be cut down to size before any deals can be made and the needs of the tribals met.
 
Back