Does it make sense to buy 4G phone now?

  • Thread starter Thread starter arijitmitter
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 19
  • Views Views 6,521

arijitmitter

Newbie
Messages
130
Location
NA
ISP
BSNL DataOne
If I go back to 2003 (about July), Reliance Infocomm rolled out CDMA service and came out with Nokia 2280 a CDMA version of the GSM bestseller Nokia 3310/15. The phone was priced at Rs 10,800 to be paid in 36 instalments of Rs 300.

Call rates were about Re 1/min, unheard of at that time. They added millions of customers who paid Rs 500 down payment and took home a phone. The impact was immediate. Cell phone companies operating on the GSM spectrum drastically reduced their call charges. Cellphone makers realized the untapped market and launched far cheaper phones - by Dec 2003 Nokia 1100 cost Rs 4,000 and Samsung C100 with 65K color screen and polyphonic ringtone (cutting edge tech at that time) was selling for Rs 8,000.

Within 3 months this
114.jpg

cost about Rs 3,000 less than this !!
spare-parts-accessories-for-nokia-2280-maxbhi-4-9-1.jpg


People dumped the R-Com Nokia 2280, refused to pay the remaining instalments and switched to GSM because of the ease with which one could buy new cheap handsets with more features. Reliance countered with Motorola C131 handsets priced at Rs 3,000.

If I look back at Nokia 2280 fiasco (many like my sister paid the entire Rs 10,800 over 3 years and swore never to buy Reliance again) should I wait for other companies waiting to dump Rs 4,000 LTE phones in the market or come up with a system like the US where handsets are subsidized (there are Rs 4,000 LTE phones now but they are very basic and have bad battery backup).

Does it make sense to buy 4G phone / home wifi device / dongle now or wait six months (unless one already owns one). What I am trying to say is, in 2003 the game changed very fast .. in six months the entire mobile scenario was different .. completely new handsets and mobile plans appeared out of thin air at very cheap prices. While in January 2003 executives carried a brick phone and paid Rs 8 for outgoing, by 2004 end everyone (including the local sabziwalla) had a sleek mobile.

P.S - all dates and amounts are from memory; any error is unintentional and regretted
P.P.S - this is posted in R-Jio section because any valuable contribution on this point can only be made by those visiting broadbandforum and directly clicking R-Jio subsection link. Those who are not interested in 4G are not visiting R-Jio subsection and hence cannot answer (if this is posted elsewhere on the forum).
 
Last edited:
mmm. you do not pay extra to buy a 4g phone. most phones already are 4g capable and they work just fine on wireless networks. the situation today is very different from the times of rcom launch. the phones are not locked to any carrier. mobile number portability exists so you are not stuck with the operator.
 
As per some news, 70~80% Smartphones sold in India last year were 4G Capable.
So Yes, it totally makes sense to buy 4G ready "Smartphone" now.
 
I added a phrase - unless one already owns one. I am stuck with a 3G phone bought last year. Paisa vasool nahi hua abhi tak. And I am hopeful that 3G prices may drop.

Basically should I buy a 4G this Deepavali (end Oct) or wait till March and see if a flood of phones and plan offers as we saw between Oct 2003 and Mar 2004 happen.
 
Last edited:
i have access to airtel 4g but i stay on airtel 3g when i am out. lte kills battery fast and i really don't mind waiting an extra second for web pages to load. but it's good to have an option to use lte when i do need faster speeds (if it is indeed faster than 3g).
 
exactly. there is no reason to buy a 4g phone unless you want to move to jio.
 
As per some news, 70~80% Smartphones sold in India last year were 4G Capable.

There's a huge catch here. Although these handsets are 4G capable, they might or might not be VoLTE capable. All the phones that I have at home are 4G capable but there's no VoLTE support in even one of them. And yes, you can still dial/receive calls using the Jio4GVoice app but the app is really buggy and laggy.
 
As per some news, 70~80% Smartphones sold in India last year were 4G Capable.
So Yes, it totally makes sense to buy 4G ready "Smartphone" now.

Please read what I wrote carefully (not being rude). That is why I shared images of Nokia 2280 at Rs 10,800 vs Samsung C100 at Rs 8,000.

Yes there are many 4G phones .. but 2003 - 2004 saw huge price drop and feature explosion. What if the phone that costs Rs 10,000 today costs Rs 4,000 in six months (that is the kind of drop we saw in 03 - 04). 70% smart phones sold last year were 4G capable but they have pathetic battery and 1 GB RAM.

Does it make sense to see if 3,500 mah battery and 2 GB RAM VoLTE phones drop to Rs 6,000 price point? I know no one here is a fortune teller but what would you advice for someone who can buy one Rs 8,000 phone every two years.
 
phones costing 10,000 rupees today would disappear from the market in a year or so. most phones do not get cheaper, they disappear. they would not drop to 4000 rupees because companies do not continue making stocks of phones for ever these days. you might get lucky and get a great deal during stock clearance but in most cases, these phones do not lose this much value over a period of time. feature phones were different. the phone you purchased in 2005 would still work just fine today for the purpose it was designed for.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SVK
Back