Apple macOS

And finally, it is a luxury item. The iPhone is not considered a basic cost of living in America even though it is here where Apple has made its real money. I notice Indians don't spend any money on Apple services. Who do you think actually buys audio and video from iTunes?..it is Americans not Indians so Apple knows it has to give the product at a subsidized rate so that it can even more money with content. You forget that in your analysis.

indians do not buy stuff from itunes because apple does not allow us to. if you are going raise the point that we would still not buy stuff? well i bet a lot of americans too do not buy their stuff from online media stores preferring to take the cheaper way out.

we are used to paying 15-35000 rupees for a mobile phone. i dont think we would mind paying for music and movies if we get them at comparable rates to america (adjusted to per capita income).

in fact... most high end theaters in metro cities charge almost the same money for a movie ticket as in USA. i heard 8-16 dollars is the price range for movie tickets in america... here in gurgaon tickets can cost anywhere between 125 rupees to 950 rupees. :) and we still manage to fill the theaters (avatar launch was a great example)... even with OUR INCOME LEVELS. :)

Apple iPhone is subsidized for sure. but you have it. we do not have the iphone 3gs on sale in india. subsidized or not.

if we take into consideration the per capita income... what you spend on mobile charges... it is i guess comparable to what we pay for it.

but take the same case for broadband charges... we pay a lot more for a lot less.

honda accord is considered a mid range sedan in usa... it is a freaking luxury car in india. and we pay more for the same car here in india. despite having a much lower purchasing power. ;)

india is still going to become a larger automotive market in the coming years. it is only the cheap cars where we have some advantage. but the difference is NOTHING if we compare the per capita income...

in simple terms... if we compare how much a typical indian and american earns... indians end up paying a lot more for the same stuff. healthcare might be an exception. but that is mostly because your politicians have planned it that ways. and ours is going on the same route.

it has become pretty much unaffordable for a middle class man to get treatment in the best hospital in the city... the treatment is still hell cheaper than what it costs in USA. but it has become just too expensive for us. especially in the metro cities.

casual illnesses? we are at a major advantage there. :)

and of course... india provides a very cheap medical tourism destination for americans. and its the indian education system backed by the indian government that enables us to do that.
 
indians do not buy stuff from itunes because Apple does not allow us to. if you are going raise the point that we would still not buy stuff? well i bet a lot of americans too do not buy their stuff from online media stores preferring to take the cheaper way out.

we are used to paying 15-35000 rupees for a mobile phone. i dont think we would mind paying for music and movies if we get them at comparable rates to america (adjusted to per capita income).

in fact... most high end theaters in metro cities charge almost the same money for a movie ticket as in USA. i heard 8-16 dollars is the price range for movie tickets in america... here in gurgaon tickets can cost anywhere between 125 rupees to 950 rupees. :) and we still manage to fill the theaters (avatar launch was a great example)... even with OUR INCOME LEVELS. :)

apple iPhone is subsidized for sure. but you have it. we do not have the iphone 3gs on sale in india. subsidized or not.

if we take into consideration the per capita income... what you spend on mobile charges... it is i guess comparable to what we pay for it.

but take the same case for broadband charges... we pay a lot more for a lot less.

honda accord is considered a mid range sedan in usa... it is a freaking luxury car in india. and we pay more for the same car here in india. despite having a much lower purchasing power. ;)

india is still going to become a larger automotive market in the coming years. it is only the cheap cars where we have some advantage. but the difference is NOTHING if we compare the per capita income...

in simple terms... if we compare how much a typical indian and american earns... indians end up paying a lot more for the same stuff. healthcare might be an exception. but that is mostly because your politicians have planned it that ways. and ours is going on the same route.

it has become pretty much unaffordable for a middle class man to get treatment in the best hospital in the city... the treatment is still hell cheaper than what it costs in USA. but it has become just too expensive for us. especially in the metro cities.

casual illnesses? we are at a major advantage there. :)

and of course... india provides a very cheap medical tourism destination for americans. and its the indian education system backed by the indian government that enables us to do that.

In my normal middle class suburb, normal theaters are in the $10-16 range depending on showtime. In India, you do not have to goto a high end theater. I have been to plenty of theaters in India and you can get tickets easily for less than $5. You need not goto a high end theater. A high end theater in the United States will cost you more than $30. Movies in America are not considered a basic cost of living..it is considered to be a leisure activity.

Again...cell phones..you left out the cost of the service. Re-read my post on the subscriber revenues. You can pay 35000 rupees for a handset because of dirt cheap cell phone service costs. That is why I provided the minimum cost of iphone ownership which includes device + service cost. People here have no reason to pay full price for the phone because the high service cost will be there no matter what..so most have to bite the bullet and get into a two year contract in order to save a few hundred dollars. Without the contract, the TCO of the iphone would go up to $2500 for two years versus only $1000 in India.

As far as the Honda, well don't buy it. Go buy yourself a dirt cheap Tata Nano for $2500 or a Maruti for less than $6000. Or the Reva electric car for $7000. There are no such options in the USA. Also, India has a cheap, efficient public transportation system...so you can take the train. With few exception, US public transport is a complete joke. The car is a necessity in US life. Always has been. That is why there are 250 million passenger cars in the US alone while the rest of the world accounts for 350 million cars. The US is three times larger than India with low population density so a car is a necessity. I average 90 miles round trip every day for work. Others much more. There are only 9 million four wheel passenger cars in India because it is not a necessity...not because of the cost.

You have plenty of dirt cheap cars...open your eyes to Indian made cars which operate just fine for the basic purpose. The average price of a car sold in India is less than $15000 while in the USA it is $28000. Why? Because you have plenty of cheap Indian made cars at your disposable which people do buy. You did not mention that an Indian electric car like the Reva will cost three times the price in the USA once it goes on sale here. You also left out the cost of liability insurance and the cost of car repairs. In America, car servicing is far more expensive than in India. By the time I am done with the cost of insurance and maintenance and repairs for my Accord, it will be the same price as you total cost of ownership. But, for me, the Accord is a necessity while for you it is a luxury because in India you have the train, the bus, auto rickshaw or cheap Tata Nano/Maruti at your disposal.

As far as Honda, it has sold its Accord in the US since the 1970's. Japan and the USA have engaged in free trade for more than 100 years not counting the World War II years. We have had free trade agreements with Japan that call for little or no import duties during that time. Both nations have spent trillions on infrastructure. India has never had that kind of relationship with Japan or anybody else. So, yes, a Honda Accord is cheaper here but that is because of the largest economic relationship between two countries over the last 100 years...the US and Japan. People in India do not understand the huge economic relationship and history between America and Japan. And, it has come at a price..the loss of jobs in the American auto industry due to the free trade with Japan. So, you are unwilling to engage in true free trade and spend the money on infrastructure so that Honda can sell its car in India for the same if not cheaper price than the USA.

As far as broadband charges in India, well, again..spend the money on infrastructure. Total miles of fiber optics in the USA is highest in the world. We paid for the infrastructure so that we could have excellent broadband services. And, I have seen MTNL's prices. They are not expensive. You can get basic broadband for $5. It may not be fast but at least you can get the service. No provider in the USA can offer a basic level of broadband for $5.

And, the internet was paid for by th American taxpayer. It is an American technology. If you find it expensive, it goes back to my previous question of why don't you spend money on infrastructure and technology so that you can have lower prices. You want our technology at our prices but are not willing to spend the trillions of dollars up front that we have spent over the last 50 years or so.

We have the iphone because some Americans developed it. Again, why don't you develop your own technology including consumer electronics? On one hand Indians talk about being smarter than Americans and that may very well be the case on average but it appears at the very top you lack creativity which I guess you guys are ready to kiss Steve Jobs and he actually isn't even the real brains behind Apple...it was Wozniak but Jobs is more of the shark. So, you crave the iPhone and complain about price but do nothing with your own brains to change the situation.

If nothing else drives home the point regarding the cost of living, the US spends 10 trillion dollars on consumption with a population of 310 million people while India only spends not more than $400 billion and that too with a population of 1.2 billion. The US spends more on healthcare, education, energy, education, cars and infrastructure individually than India spends in the aggregate. So, no point in comparing a specific item to a specific item...look at the total numbers in aggregate or across various sectors.

Why would Apple waste its time with itunes in India? The cost of Apple products in India today is lower than what it was in the United States in 1985. Apple computers in 1985 in 2009 dollars would cost about $4000 dollars yet sales in the USA for Apple in 1985 are far higher than what Apple is selling in India in 2009 at prices far below $4000 so it is not the cost that explains such low sales for Apple in India.

India spends only $ 5 billion dollars total on electronics...the US spends $ 170 billion and the rest of the world accounts for another $500 billion. The US spends $2.5 trillion on healthcare and yet still manages to spend more on electronics than anybody else including India? The fact that you have saved all that money from healthcare and still have low consumption of electronics cannot be explained away just by cost. If you had American healthcare costs your total would be $10 trillion instead of just $72 billion. All that money you have saved could be spent on Apple products but that is not the case either. The reality is India is just not that large of a market compared to the US, Japan, Europe, China, Russia and Brazil.

Public universities in America receive funding from the various state governments and still cost individuals $100,000 for a bachelor's degree. All major universities receive some sort of funding from various arms of the US government. That does not explain the difference in the cost of education. The Indian government is not spending 500 billion dollars a year to subsidize Indian universities.
 
There are no such options in the USA.

from what i have heard... second hand car market is actually pretty huge in the USA and you can actually buy a BMW in a good condition for a great price. now that is something i had like to own rather than a tata nano which is a joke in the name of a car. safety standards here are crap compared to USA and Europe... so essentially... you get better and much safer cars... tata nano might cost USD 2500 in india but the same model with compulsory upgrades would probably cost double in the USA. add some extra money and buy a second hand sedan. safe and luxurious.

Also, India has a cheap, efficient public transportation system...so you can take the train.

you have to be kidding. indian public transport system is in a mess. of course USA is not doing any better. i have read enough stories on reddit and digg on how oil companies ensured that the public transport system suck so that every person has to buy a car for basic things like shopping for home items. :) at least in usa you have a pretty vast network of metros... we are just starting with that. :)

usa has excellent broadband services? that is news for me. from what i have heard... you are in a pretty messy condition. your government is against network neutrality... european (sweden) and south east asian countries (south korea, japan) have much much better networks. you might have invented the internet... but your own companies (att, comcast etc) are working on killing it for you.

internet is not OWNED by america. you developed the base of the internet. it is now powered by companies around the world. it is a global phenomena. i think i have given this example previously also. india invented the zero. zero is part of the binary system which forms the base of computers. without computers... internet? mmm. sorry.

i guess since ford made the first car... you guys are responsible for the tata nano we have today... i guess its a shame that toyota and volkswagen is kicking ford and GM's ass in the automotive market. you guys invented the car. but japanese companies are now dominating your companies in your country. nice job usa!

i really pity you if you think america is doing well... america is deep in debts and most of it is from china. in real world... china owns usa's ass. but then... you are not really prepared to handle the reality. :)

the amount of power china has today is mind boggling. in reality... each and every one of us should be scared of china... they are the real superpowers of this world.
 
from what i have heard... second hand car market is actually pretty huge in the USA and you can actually buy a BMW in a good condition for a great price. now that is something i had like to own rather than a tata nano which is a joke in the name of a car. safety standards here are crap compared to USA and Europe... so essentially... you get better and much safer cars... tata nano might cost USD 2500 in india but the same model with compulsory upgrades would probably cost double in the USA. add some extra money and buy a second hand sedan. safe and luxurious.

you have to be kidding. indian public transport system is in a mess. of course USA is not doing any better. i have read enough stories on reddit and digg on how oil companies ensured that the public transport system suck so that every person has to buy a car for basic things like shopping for home items. :) at least in usa you have a pretty vast network of metros... we are just starting with that. :)

usa has excellent broadband services? that is news for me. from what i have heard... you are in a pretty messy condition. your government is against network neutrality... european (sweden) and south east asian countries (south korea, japan) have much much better networks. you might have invented the internet... but your own companies (att, comcast etc) are working on killing it for you.

internet is not OWNED by america. you developed the base of the internet. it is now powered by companies around the world. it is a global phenomena. i think i have given this example previously also. india invented the zero. zero is part of the binary system which forms the base of computers. without computers... internet? mmm. sorry.

i guess since ford made the first car... you guys are responsible for the tata nano we have today... i guess its a shame that toyota and volkswagen is kicking ford and GM's ass in the automotive market. you guys invented the car. but japanese companies are now dominating your companies in your country. nice job usa!

i really pity you if you think america is doing well... america is deep in debts and most of it is from china. in real world... china owns usa's ass. but then... you are not really prepared to handle the reality. :)

the amount of power china has today is mind boggling. in reality... each and every one of us should be scared of china... they are the real superpowers of this world.

You failed to reply to the substance of most points. The BMW is not a necessity in American life or Indian life. A car in American life is a necessity...not in India. That is why only 9 million passenger cars are registered in India. The Maruti works just fine at $6000 dollars and the Reva also. We have no such options. Yes...the Big three got it handed to them by the Japanese..free trade..lower prices for the Honda...and millions of Americans out of work who have no money to buy that Accord no matter what the price is. Infrastructure expenditures in Japan and the USA. I suggest you re-read what I wrote. The same relationship exists between Germany and the United States. You ignored the cost of infrastructure and free trade which enables lower prices on luxury items like a BMW. India is not willing to spend the money or risk jobs for those lower prices on non-essential items like BMWs.

I knew you would mention \"zero\" but that was a long time ago. India never did anything to build on \"zero\" while the Europeans/Americans did. For how long can Indians claim their fame to \"zero\" in today's world?

American broadband. I have Verizon FIOS with 25 down/ 5 up. The service is excellent. There are 50 million broadband connections in the USA highest in the world. Sweden, Japan, South Korea have excellent services. They are also very small countries with sufficient population density. They can cover their entire countries with broadband access easily. No American company is going to connect rural America with the necessary infrastructure...too expensive...low population density...they cannot make money at least so they say so broadband penetration number in the US never look as good when you compare it to Europe and Asia. What is India's excuse...you have the population, manpower, and necessary density for every home in every major city to be connected by fiber. Why did that not happen thirty years ago? In the USA, the entire fiber backbone was complete during the early 1980s but the telecommunication companies decided that it was too expensive to run the last mile to homes and stuck with the copper.

I do not take issue about network neutrality and the efforts of Comcast, AT&T etc to kill it. At times their behavior is against the better public interest. But technology is not the issue...America has had it for a long time The DOCSIS standard for Cable and most research and development of fiber optics occurred in the US.
 
My only point being- It is not those who pay 60 for healthcare that are looking to buy macbooks. Let me try and explain this- India has a huge income gap10% earn alot more than 90%Now overall the figures are low because 90% outwieghs the 10%But These 10% amount to alot of people and they are the ones looking to buy.The Buying power they have is immense.and how does it matter who did what and who paid for what?with globalization, everyone is dependent on everyoneUSA can afford low prices because of countries like India and China.But thats not the point.we live in one world that is so closely connected. If there is one thing I can say. Living in India kicks Americas ass.Where else can you live like a King?And that is the ultimate point.Not to mention- India is a happier country Than the US of Aand that is even more importantWhen it comes to whose done what-USA has been free for 200 odd years(I may be wrong on the number) and India 60.At the end of the day india is far better equipped and developed than those nation that share its history.
 
The Maruti works just fine at $6000 dollars and the Reva also. We have no such options.

I have lived in a metro city all my life. And I can assure you that car is a necessity here in India. and a small car does not work out. because a lot of families still live together. so if you have enough money, you would end up buying a big enough MUV or multiple cars to accommodate all the people in the family. my dad could not afford a car. we lived without one for most of our lives. but we had four cars at one point of time. because they all were needed. now we have three. and all of these three are 'needed'. public transport just does not work out because of the messy last mile connectivity. public transport is a mess due to excessive population. ever tried traveling in a bus in mumbai or delhi? ever tried dealing with an autorickshaw wala? you would feel the need to own a personal transport.

metro is perhaps the only saving grace in delhi. but it is already suffering due to excessive loads on the busy routes. the government is working on infrastructure that fails to handle the load of current population levels. in 10 years time... it is going to be messier.

tata nano has been hailed as the car for the common man. sadly... we do not have the roads to accomodate too many Nanos on our roads. but no one is stopping tata from selling it and no one is stopping the common man for buying it. reality is... using public transport is often a necessity because you cannot afford a personal vehicle.

i still remember that day when i was stuck in a state owned bus on a 20 KM journey which took 2.5 hours because of the traffic. it was at the peak of summers. i told myself that day... no matter what i have to do... i have to get myself a bike so that i never have to end up in a similar situation again. i can think about traveling around in a metro... but state government owned buses? no thanks. and i am from a typical middle class family.

you have the population, manpower, and necessary density for every home in every major city to be connected by fiber.

we also have poverty, illiteracy, corruption... broadband is not a necessity when you do not have access to clean drinking water or even food.

the fact remains... india is surviving with all the insanities it has. i am not sure a typical american can do the same if he is put in our situation. :)
 
My only point being- It is not those who pay 60 for healthcare that are looking to buy macbooks.
Let me try and explain this- India has a huge income gap
10% earn alot more than 90%
Now overall the figures are low because 90% outwieghs the 10%
But These 10% amount to alot of people and they are the ones looking to buy.
The Buying power they have is immense.
and how does it matter who did what and who paid for what?
with globalization, everyone is dependent on everyone
USA can afford low prices because of countries like India and China.
But thats not the point.
we live in one world that is so closely connected.
If there is one thing I can say. Living in India kicks Americas ass.
Where else can you live like a King?
And that is the ultimate point.
Not to mention- India is a happier country Than the US of A
and that is even more important

When it comes to whose done what-
USA has been free for 200 odd years(I may be wrong on the number) and India 60.
At the end of the day india is far better equipped and developed than those nation that share its history.

Well. Really nothing in your last post that I disagree with. But you really have not explained the lack of creativity or developments. The Chinese are trying to make their own things...they will kick out the foreigners once they have learned everything they want to learn. You mention macbooks? Where is the Indian version? India is big enough, has the manpower, the brains...Shouldn't India be a major player that can make low cost computers rather than depend on overpriced macbooks?

Linus Torvalds did not sit around and worry about Windows or Mac..and we see the small but noticeable impact of Linux.
 
i would generally talk about brain drain here. but that is an excuse used very often in these kinds of discussions. a typical engineer or an MBA in india is more concerned about making a living. changing the world is often not part of the to-do list. most of these smart people come from fairly poor background. and they tend to play it safe and take regular well paying jobs. the smarter ones with better resources tend to move out. india is a bad example here anyways. i have already admitted that we suck at looking at the future. the corruption that is part of our culture means that we are going to remain a developing country for a long long time. china on the other hand is doing it all right. they developed their own 3G standard. they are also working on their own microprocessor technology. they are also working on a new generation of engineers who would be comfortable with the english language. in around 5-10 years time... india would probably lose the advantage of being a cheap alternative for outsourcing. china already has the hardware manufacturing... they would soon take on the software side and support as well. usa would continue to remain dependent upon china and india would probably be crying over spilled milk :)i am a pessimist when i look at the future of india. what is your opinion about where usa would be in 10 years time?
 
i would generally talk about brain drain here. but that is an excuse used very often in these kinds of discussions.

a typical engineer or an MBA in india is more concerned about making a living. changing the world is often not part of the to-do list.

most of these smart people come from fairly poor background. and they tend to play it safe and take regular well paying jobs.

the smarter ones with better resources tend to move out.

india is a bad example here anyways. i have already admitted that we suck at looking at the future. the corruption that is part of our culture means that we are going to remain a developing country for a long long time.

china on the other hand is doing it all right. they developed their own 3G standard. they are also working on their own microprocessor technology. they are also working on a new generation of engineers who would be comfortable with the english language.

in around 5-10 years time... india would probably lose the advantage of being a cheap alternative for outsourcing. china already has the hardware manufacturing... they would soon take on the software side and support as well.

usa would continue to remain dependent upon china and india would probably be crying over spilled milk :)

i am a pessimist when i look at the future of india. what is your opinion about where usa would be in 10 years time?

I do agree with you that brain drain is not the problem for India. The cream of the crop Indian brains for the most part are in India. The government of India won't let go of certain people. I think there maybe 40 million people of Indian origin outside of India which is just a tiny fraction of the motherland. NRIs have done well as in making money but it doesn't mean we are a group of people who if we were still in India would be developing and creating new technologies and making India a better place to live in.

I would remain pessimistic about India because infrastructure (roads, energy, telecommunications) are critical to any major economy and for whatever reason India is not making the kind of progress China has which is necessary. China is surrounding India in its own neighborhood through its relations with Pakistan, Sri Lanka and even now Nepal with the Maoists in charge over there.

The USA. Well. The unemployment is a real concern. 10% officially but that only takes into account people who are collecting unemployment benefits. The actual total is over 20% which takes into account people who are not eligible for unemployment benefits as well as people who are "discouraged" and have given up their job search.

No jobs means no money to spend and 70% of the US economy is due to consumption. There has to be a manufacturing base but that means higher prices for goods and nobody wants that. They bash China but run to the store to purchase products which are manufactured there. The higher income groups are never going to complain about the arrangement. It is the middle and lower income groups that get screwed since they are more likely to be in manufacturing.

You are correct. China is in a very powerful position and the United States has pretty much accepted that reality.
 
Back