Barkha Dutt

  • Thread starter Thread starter Sushubh
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 15
  • Views Views 3,645
Media's job is news reporting, and not passing judgement and turning anybody convict or guilty.

So which news anchor do you like then and why ?

Lets see how confident you are with the answer :)

I like DD NEWS & NEWSX anchors, as they do 'News Reporting' and dont behave like SC judges, and I also like Sunetra Choudhury :imwink:
 
Media's job is news reporting, and not passing judgement and turning anybody convict or guilty.
What a loaded statement :)

Yes, they should report the news, but they cannot convict anybody even if they tried. Very fine line they tread there or get sued for libel or defamation. When's the last time you heard somebody sue them ?

So whats wrong, especially with some irritating topics where there is no progress at all, don't you want somebody to ask the hard questions. I want them to tease out as much info from their guests and you cannot get that much by being gentle & nice.


I like DD NEWS & NEWSX anchors, as they do 'News Reporting' and dont behave like SC judges, and I also like Sunetra Choudhury :imwink:
hmm sunetra is a bit bland for my tastes not much spark along with Vishnu. Vikram is better. Then again after watching Arnab i find CNN & BBC are just as boring. CNN is the worst, the anchors there seem like robots and the accent just gets up my nose.

There was one journalist from NDTV, that i thought was very good, she's not much to look at but very sharp. She interviewed the google marketing head and really took him to task, not missing a beat or his deflections along the way. It was scripted but it felt completely improvised.

I don't rely on these ppl to give me the news, i can get much better from the newspapers, its more the interactions with guests over certain breaking topics that is of interest. There is an extra dimension which i missed earlier that you get with these shows which newspapers cannot replicate. So my preference is for hosts that are hard nosed with their guests. This is where the talking points come about.

Arnab finished his show one night with this line..

let me tell you its been a pleasure to bring you the news tonight

How many anchors say that ? Connect with their audiences in this way.

I certainly have not heard many. It reminds me of some of the famous foreign anchors that really personalise the show to the point it becomes an institution. They hook you and you spend the next couple of decades listening to them.

How to tell what the TRP ratings are for these various shows, anybody know where to find a table with those numbers ?

It would be interesting to see how these various personalities stack up in a shootout.
 
Even the cub reporters are presenting the news as analysts and editors; their job is just to report what has happened or is happening; but they spend 90% of the time in doing what they are should not.
 
Even the cub reporters are presenting the news as analysts and editors; their job is just to report what has happened or is happening; but they spend 90% of the time in doing what they are should not.
I'm having trouble reading your mind here -- can you explain what you mean by 'doing what they should not' ?

Give examples.

Actually SVK you can jump in here as well and define (with examples) what passing judgement means. I find it too general a description.

All i can tell is what you see as SC judge behaviour as nothing more than a 'call to action' from the parties concerned. Which is exactly what the people following a case want to see. I can't fault an anchor for doing so.

Lets take that case of the minor that got raped by a BSP MLA and to add insult to injury ended up getting jailed for theft. Arnab was out there demanding to know why Mayawati was silent. Why was she silent ? It happened at the end of Dec 31, to date this girl is still in jail.

The most reasonable reaction one can expect in this instance is : WTF :)

Yes or no ?
 
Every event happening can have 2 sides. Take e.g. of Aarushi case, where CBI is closing case, but media already made her father convict. Then I remember there were few stories where media immediately proclaimed some convicts as criminals (khooni darinda Star News/Aaj Tak style), while in reality it may turn out that convict was innocent. And 1 popular example I would give is of Sachin. 2-3 years back Star News (I had access to only that channel) was targetting Sachin for every match loss due to his bad form. And see now today, the same channel comes up with dedicated programmes for him with 'Exclusive' interviews. So on many such examples we can see that NEWS channels act to give judgement, while they should just stick to 'delivering news'.
 
Every event happening can have 2 sides.
Sure, which is why ruling & opposition spokesmen are always there.

Take e.g. of Aarushi case, where CBI is closing case, but media already made her father convict.
Slight correction here, its the CBI that said they think the father did it.

Which was pretty damn obvious isn't it. This was clear right from the start but nobody could say anything until the case reached its conclusion where we were told, lo & behold 'nobody killed Arushi'. Why ?

The evidence was tampered with and there is no way now ever to convict anybody. The best that could be done was to cast aspersions and this is the level the mighty CBI was reduced to.

The fact that the evidence was clearly professionaly tampered with makes the father's behaviour and involvement in this case very suspect. Is this the behaviour of somebody that wants his daughter's murderer apprehended or somebody that wants to
a) make it impossible for anybody to be convicted
b) hide the fact that his daughter made out with a lowly cook and he lost his temper.

Then I remember there were few stories where media immediately proclaimed some convicts as criminals (khooni darinda Star News/Aaj Tak style), while in reality it may turn out that convict was innocent.
ok

And 1 popular example I would give is of Sachin. 2-3 years back Star News (I had access to only that channel) was targetting Sachin for every match loss due to his bad form. And see now today, the same channel comes up with dedicated programmes for him with 'Exclusive' interviews. So on many such examples we can see that NEWS channels act to give judgement, while they should just stick to 'delivering news'.
This is a good example of bad ethics and i would agree with you in this particular instance.
 
Back