I am not passing judgement here. But we saw what happened with 3G auction. My personal thought process suggests that 2G was indeed sold at very low costs, and some people ,ahem, made "profits", made lots of "profits", but I am not sure if the 2G auction would have brought the right results. And already I am reading that there might be a lukewarm response to the revised 2G auction
Incumbent telecom firms like Bharti Airtel, Vodafone may skip 2G spectrum auction - The Economic Times
Brokerage firms, analysts and industry experts have warned that the upcoming 2G airwaves auction may fail to yield the desired results, with some even stating that auctions may be a failure, as incumbent and new mobile phone companies are unlikely to bid for spectrum in the top seven circles that make up 80% of the Rs 14,000-crore base price.
"Incumbents like Bharti Airtel and Vodafone have enough spectrum and hence would not require to bid in the auctions. If they bid, the auction-determined price would be used against them when their licences come up for renewal, and therefore they may not bid to avoid a double cash outgo," said UBS analyst Suresh Mahadevan.
UBS in a note to its clients said that it would be in the 'best interest of all stakeholders to not bid for the top seven service areas, as doing so would result in economic as well as accounting losses,' while adding that it did not make 'logical sense' for Telenor and Sistema to bid at these high prices since they're already making significant losses from current operations.