Ganesh Prasad: How Does the Capitalist View Open Source?

I think its a false dichotomy to say open source is either when it has elements of both and then some. Those articles were written to counter m$ asssertions (primarily steve ballmer's) which were nothing but propaganda. Easily digestible and to print. Also does not discuss BSD's model which has no problems with making money off its work but is nevertheless still open source. GPL is not the only open source game in town.Lots of programs in open source, but once the program gets to a significant size it going to consume lots of resources. The kernel, firefox, GNOME, KDE along with some others tho these would prolly be in the top 5 % of open source projects can sustain themselves and stil give it out for free. They are the exceptions.What would be more interesting is to see is whether open-source can overtake for-pay software in terms of ideas etc, rather than merely playing catch-up.
 
Right.. my post got lost in the "vBSEO update" whatever that means.

So basically, I don't think the open source initiative's philosophy needs to be supported using Ayn rand's ideologies. It's like using props or scaffolding to support something that's already strong and stable. THe justification sounds defensive and you cannot get away wtih statements like Ayn Rand never wrote about software in her lifetime, but she surely would have recognized it as wealth. Indeed, if Rand were to write "The Fountainhead" today, her hero might very well be a programmer rather than an architect. Nothing epitomizes individual human creativity as well as software, being the product of pure mind.

@blr_p: No, open source source movement DOES NOT play catch up. Lots of hand waving in that statement. Yes, tHere are some areas where you need to be slightly confirmist to get people to adopt but in terms of technology, OSS has been way ahead.
 
Economics lies at the root of everything and Ayn Rand and Milton Friedman were the champions of individuals and their freedom - economic or otherwise. So, Ayn Rand = scaffolding? I don't agree. If Rand is a strange figure, where would you put Richard 'GNU or I won't speak' Stallman. He too defends his copyleft-ivity as strongly.

The confusion begins with the licenses - there are so many. What does each one do? Can I use code from a MPLed software if I release mine under GPL? I am not sure. Maybe yes, maybe no.
Licenses by Name | Open Source Initiative

But who really cares about all this. For the end user, it is mostly about money. Open Source Software = Free Software = I don't have to pay for it. If the company is big enough, it might modify the software for its needs. But for the vast majority of users who don't know how to write software (and even for those who do), it is a choice between picking up what is on the table vs. finding something else.

As for the philosophy part, is it not surprising that Open Source finds such strong support from countries like Cuba, Venezuela and Iran? It is a matter of philosophy for them too - an anti-american one.

I use what I find convenient - most of it is available for free. For some, I pay. But every major Open Source software that is available (GNU/Linux, Open Office, Firefox) is funded by one giant corporation or the other - and its economic might. Writing software takes time and time has to be paid for. That is something that cannot be wished away.
 
Economics lies at the root of everything and Ayn Rand and Milton Friedman were the champions of individuals and their freedom - economic or otherwise.

Economics is almost at the root of everything. THen there is also right of freedom, next in line after 'roti, kapda aur makaan.' The FOSS movement is more about the freedom to use/modify/copy software than the cost associated with using it for free. Ayn Rand deals predominantly with how capitalism is meritocratic and hence superior than more socialistic economies; whereas those associated with FOSS don't necessarily consider themselves "movers of the society" or some such tosh - they merely write software to free themselves and other users from the clutches of proprieteryship. Money here is a means to the end and not in the end in itself. Which is why Microsoft is an incorporation(whose goal is to maximise the revenue of its shareholders) and mozilla is a foundation(that writes software and pledges donation to cover costs). That was the reason I found it strange to draw parallels or analogies between ayn rand's works and the free software movement.

The confusion begins with the licenses - there are so many. What does each one do? Can I use code from a MPLed software if I release mine under GPL? I am not sure. Maybe yes, maybe no.
Licenses by Name | Open Source Initiative

THe confusion begins and ends there, doesnt it? As a lay user, how am I bothered what license the software is released under. Anyways all licenses give you the freedom to reuse, copy and modify the code, the subtle pedantic differences creep in mainly while merging or giving back. In any case, IMHO that's the last thing that would deter someone setting out to write something.

But who really cares about all this. For the end user, it is mostly about money. Open Source Software = Free Software = I don't have to pay for it. If the company is big enough, it might modify the software for its needs. But for the vast majority of users who don't know how to write software (and even for those who do), it is a choice between picking up what is on the table vs. finding something else.

Yes for most of us, its the "I dont have to pay for it" part. For some including me it's that, PLUS I can configure/tweak/hack it to my tastes and liking without being encumbered part also thats equally important. Think Mozilla vs IE.

As for the philosophy part, is it not surprising that Open Source finds such strong support from countries like Cuba, Venezuela and Iran? It is a matter of philosophy for them too - an anti-american one.

Equally surprising, there are plenty of contributors from the European states as well. Some of them like the scandinavian countries, have a very socialistic outlook for govenance. Interestingly, the countries you've mentioned are ones with oppresive regimes.

I use what I find convenient - most of it is available for free. For some, I pay. But every major Open Source software that is available (GNU/Linux, Open Office, Firefox) is funded by one giant corporation or the other - and its economic might. Writing software takes time and time has to be paid for. That is something that cannot be wished away.

Yeah, that often comes after the project has reached a certain size, when a big corporation sees sense and self interest in adopting/funding these for their good. THese are standing testimonies to the fact that it is economically viable, under certain conditons, whcih is why in the first place I felt it doesn't need supporting ANALogies from tangential philosophies. [Hint: Check out the comments at the end of Ganesh Prasad's article]
 
The thing about Open Source as a philosophy (and it is one) is that it is a quagmire as far as understanding goes. That is why there are multiple prima donnas fighting it out on the basis of their understanding of what it is. And there are two different audiences for the various licenses - the programmers and the end users. As an end user, I could care less as to what it is all about because I am getting something for free. For the more concerned party, the ability to modify code is certainly important. As for the programmer wanting to contribute something back to OS, the licenses certainly matter. Otherwise what is the point of having so many?Talking about oppressive regimes, that is precisely why I mentioned them. Their view of FOSS is a twisted one - a view from the other side of the fence. That is precisely why defences of every kind are necessary. People within the fold might not need one. But those outside certainly need to know what the craze is all about.The fact that big companies are putting their money into such a undertaking might show that they are committed to their shareholders. Why waste 5 billion dollars on a bloated OS when a fraction of the sum might generate more profitable software on a ROI basis? What needs to happen is that the idea of FOSS as some marxist/ socialist plot needs to be laid to rest. If it makes money, it is good.Greed is good. Long live Gordon Gekko.
 
As for the philosophy part, is it not surprising that Open Source finds such strong support from countries like Cuba, Venezuela and Iran? It is a matter of philosophy for them too - an anti-american one.

Red herring, these countries came after-the-fact. Open source did not orginate in these countries, did it :), they are just using it as a platform.

I don't feel this taints open source in anyway as there are prolly far more inherently capitalist entities actively using open-source to maximise ROi as you put it. Google & IBM are prime examples.
 
Yes, Open Source did not originate there. But they are certainly putting a 'socialist' spin on it rather than talk of the freedom it provides. And for Iran, Linux is the perfect vehicle to kick Microsoft & Co. aka US imperialists out of the country. The anti-US mania (US foreign policy certainly does not help) has even touched the question of how the internet should be administered - what happens if the US decides to pull the plug on internet in Iran?There is no taint as such. But it certainly does not help matters. The 'free as in freedom' part is most important. The 'free as in free beer' part, if present, is a bonus.
 
The anti-US mania (US foreign policy certainly does not help) has even touched the question of how the internet should be administered - what happens if the US decides to pull the plug on internet in Iran?

If those complaining about US administration of the internet could come up with concrete criticisms and offer improved functionality then i think these claims would have more merit. But to date they have been just hot air. They know the US won't give it up so its a cheap way to score points, a political football.

The US screws up in lot of things, but the way the internet has been set up is not one of them. No way could it ever have grown as big & as fast otherwise. No one is forcing any country to belong to the internet, they are free to set up their own.

The US can't pull the plug on the internet in Iran unless they bomb them or maybe less expensively just threaten their upstream providers. Given that the Iranians arent exactly all that keen about free speech anyway, would prolly be counter-productive.
 
Back