Ganesh Prasad: How Does the Capitalist View Open Source?

It has got to do with US control of ICANN (ICANN - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia). These people believe the US can use its influence to cause harm to their interests if things come to such a point. That is why they want all the work done by ICANN to go to a UN body (United Nations - the name is a paradox). They know that the UN is one of the most useless and toothless organisations ever to exist. Hence they are safe from its piercing gaze.
 
The control of ICANN and the root dns is a threat to all nations and not just the middle east ones, although they would be the ones likely to be most suspicious.
 
Yeah, but the way it works is the US has this new toy and you are free to join, if you play by the rules. Otherwise you are free to setup an alternative. I don't see much improvement instead more the opposite if the UN has control over such matters. They can take several months arguing over things in the meantime matters just fester. I have more faith that the US will allow free speech over the net than any other country out there and this quality should not be upto vote.

There is another concern that might precipitate a shift if iPv4 addresses were to run and is projected to soon. Now the specs for ipV6 are already in place, but the deployment & adoption has been very slow. The US has the advantage in this situation as conceivably they could rent out addresses to the highest bidder. Many US companies, have entire Class A addresses acquired long ago. Then again so do many other countries as well. There does not seem to be much urgency on the part of these owners to give up that control in favour of ipv6. The demand for more addresses will only increase in the future. This post has more info.

Even in this situation, if the hardware to do the job rests within the US, giving decision making powers to a 3rd party is pointless. The analogy is if you have a server and you allow me to use it, if at any point we have a difference in views, all you have to do is take the server offline and reconfigure it. All i had was just virtual control .maybe this is the main point of contention after all :D, to which i say no country to date has been adversely affected, it only works if everyone cooperates, the ones crying foul are in the minority. Its a bogey, there are more scarier things the US can do than screw with internet connections.

If push comes to shove i would be in favour of a solution where no one country could kill the net. Maybe more idealistic than realistic.
 
Well, don't know too much about ipv6 except that it has an obscenely large address space and that it is somewhat backward compatible with ipv4. Western powers and US allies should not have any problems with ICANN. It is the others who are somewhat worried, and rightly so given their position.The thing is, if the US has ABSOLUTE control over everything internet, how come so many Al Qaeda videos crop up all over the net? And what happened to the 'carnivore' that the FBI was rumoured to have let loose over the net? In fact why did it need to do such a thing? These things don't match stated positions.
 
Freedom of speech, the control that you mention is only as far as making sure that DNS entries resolve to unique addresses, otherwise things would not work. There are root servers all over the world that replicate from the masters.Carnivore was to spy on data, i dont think its any different with other countries or even ours for that matter. Communicating in plain text is the equivalent of using a postcard, anyone can read its contents.
 
So, infact, it is not that difficult to create a breakaway internet. All it needs is an agreed authority and a few dns servers. Surely the 'rogue' countries can manage that between themselves. The only problem will be that the two 'internets' won't be compatible coz of clash of address space.
 
i think china is such a "rogue" or "rebellious" country... i read they are creating standard and devices with their own standards... like networking devices... and the EVD (enhanced video disc) to compete with HDDVD and BluRay etc etc...
 
Every attempt China has made in that regard has fallen flat on its face. Media formats need content to survive. And content = Hollywood.
 
Exactly there is nothing stopping countries setting up alternate DNS servers and they can also block content as with countries mentioned.You can set DNS to point to anything but then other countries are not forced to use it either. it becomes pointless.
 
It is interesting that status quo works most of the time. Wonder why people are always interested in changing things for the sake of doing so.
 
Back