India's position on Euthanasia

  • Thread starter Thread starter stalion
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 29
  • Views Views 4,235
OK, those views read coherently to me and in many European countries is the current practice.

Reason i asked..

If the position is not to permit state killing in criminal cases, then...

How to make an exception for it then in the case of euthanasia ?

If i look back at your earlier post in this thread, it appears that your answer is...

"Right to life includes right to die."

I somehow, can't understand, how anyone, can have, a right to die ?

Earlier i tried to think of examples in the animal world where suicide happens. It seems so counter evolutionary but then i thought of honey bees. It's said that a bee dies soon after it stings. Thats the way it works for the benefit of the hive as a whole. Taking one's self out for the team. Not too different to a kamikaze or suicide bomber.

But this involves 'a' cause.

There have been cases of cattle jumping off a cliff when panicked but i attribute this to herd behaviour, the animals involved are not aware of what they are doing. Or the case of roadkill where they just did not assess the situation correctly. Put it down to accidental death here.

Taking one's life wilfully for no other benefit but for oneself ??
 
I do not make an exception in the case of euthanasia. Even in that case, the demand has to come from the person in question. So, either the person should have made a living will specifying what should be done if he finds himself in a medical situation which he does not think he wants to endure, or he should make it while he is on the ventilator or whatever. I accept that there might be some cases wherein the person might not have made a living will and might not be able to take the decision in their present condition. In that case, it is up to their legal / medical proxy to make that decision for them. The Terry Schiavo case was a good example and I support the decision her husband took, and am absolutely against malicious government interference based on religious or any other grounds once the bonafides of the case have been established.

Regarding 'right to die', the concept derives itself from the idea of freedom. I have a right to live. And I am free. As a free person, I should be able to do absolutely anything as long as it does not result in injury to some one else (I am not talking about psychological injury or other variations). And since I can do that, I should also be able to kill myself if I do face such a situation. So, there is nothing strange in calling the 'right to die' a right. Why someone would want to kill himself, or let oneself be killed? There are a few examples in the animal world as you say, including the case of the black widow spider. It is a complex question but its answer lies in the idea of value. If you keep the idea of a divine puppet master, afterlife, reincarnation and all that aside, reason says that once you die, that is the absolute end of everything. So, a person must have given serious thought to it or must be real mad to take such a decision. No point talking of insane people. So, consider the idea that he has given thought to why he wants to take such a step.

1. He might be doing it to save someone he loves and / or values more than his life - wife, child, whatever (saving them from being run over by a bus, perhaps. Even if it is a split second decision, it is still a decision).

2. Money, perhaps - taking a large insurance policy, waiting out the minimum time period, and then killing himself so that his family gets the money.
Life insurance - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Joi Ito's Web: Paying for Suicide (check the second comment)

3. He might have committed a crime and would not want to go to prison and considers death to be a better alternative.

4. Another possibility is that he might be suffering from a terminal condition and does not want to endure the pain.

5. Honour. Japanese are the best example, again. Harakiri is an old practice there.

Plenty or reasons really and most of them are quite rational. As I said, it depends on the value you place on your life. If there is nothing more valuable to you than your own life (as is the case for most people), you will not let it go for anyone or anything. But sometimes, you do find that one thing that might mean more to you than your life. That particular thing is the answer to the question.
 
\"Right to life includes right to die.\"

Let's look at this again because it seems to contradict itself.

Right to life...tells me, every human being has the right to life, and it's converse, that a human being may not be deprived of it.

Right to die...says everyone also has the right to die and implies an unnatural death *not* arising as a consequence of age or sickness.

If one isn't permitted to deprive another of life then how can one ever be allowed to take one's own :)

One may not take 'a' human life, therefore any human life, including one's own, is also, not allowed.

that is, logically speaking, if we take your statement above to stand on its own.

the demand has to come from the person in question. So, either the person should have made a living will specifying what should be done if he finds himself in a medical situation which he does not think he wants to endure, or he should make it while he is on the ventilator or whatever. I accept that there might be some cases wherein the person might not have made a living will and might not be able to take the decision in their present condition.

Authorising an action based on what *may* happen in the future.

Happens all the time in legal matters. But when it involves life, especially one's own i think something more is required.

It's saying once i cross a certain threshold then hit the off button.

Problem is when you can't coherently respond back, some one else has to do this and has no way to ask your opinion about it.

So that's why you already said, via a living will, some time ago, to do it!

In that case, it is up to their legal / medical proxy to make that decision for them. The Terry Schiavo case was a good example and I support the decision her husband took, and am absolutely against malicious government interference based on religious or any other grounds once the bonafides of the case have been established.

That's fair enough i guess providing, as you say, the 'bonafides' had been established.

But then this was a very public case.

The thrust of my argument is that there has to be due diligence carried out every time such a situation arises. Legalising it may take the emphasis away in practice, so, provided the checks are stringent enough, only the cases meriting such action will be fulfilled.

Some details on regulation in a couple of countries here



Regarding 'right to die', the concept derives itself from the idea of freedom. I have a right to live. And I am free. As a free person, I should be able to do absolutely anything as long as it does not result in injury to some one else (I am not talking about psychological injury or other variations).

..with you so far.


And since I can do that, I should also be able to kill myself if I do face such a situation. So, there is nothing strange in calling the 'right to die' a right.

Contradiction :)



Why someone would want to kill himself, or let oneself be killed? It is a complex question but its answer lies in the idea of value. If you keep the idea of a divine puppet master, afterlife, reincarnation and all that aside, reason says that once you die, that is the absolute end of everything. So, a person must have given serious thought to it or must be real mad to take such a decision. No point talking of insane people. So, consider the idea that he has given thought to why he wants to take such a step.

1. He might be doing it to save someone he loves and / or values more than his life - wife, child, whatever (saving them from being run over by a bus, perhaps. Even if it is a split second decision, it is still a decision).

2. Money, perhaps - taking a large insurance policy, waiting out the minimum time period, and then killing himself so that his family gets the money.
Life insurance - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Joi Ito's Web: Paying for Suicide (check the second comment)


I'd put this down to 'for a cause' or a sacrifice :)

The benefit or value to be gained 'for others' from the action, outweighs the cost.

Still violating 'right to life' but its a trade-off in this case.

3. He might have committed a crime and would not want to go to prison and considers death to be a better alternative.

Is pronouncing death-sentence on himself for wrong doing. Price to pay here. Choose your poison, the result is inevitable either way.


Plenty or reasons really and most of them are quite rational. As I said, it depends on the value you place on your life. If there is nothing more valuable to you than your own life (as is the case for most people), you will not let it go for anyone or anything. But sometimes, you do find that one thing that might mean more to you than your life. That particular thing is the answer to the question.

When there is no direct benefit 'to others', or there are no lethal consequences of inaction.

ie its a personal choice is where i run into difficulty :)

How to rationalise it ?

We do lots of things for ourselves, we are not 'always' in the service of others.

But the ultimate price, as a personal choice, is still difficult to swallow.

In some ways i also think the decison not to legalise euthanasia or suicide is to prevent its misuse as a loophole to commit murder.
 
It should be allowed , for extraordinary cases , like someone suffering from complete paralysis or muscular dystrophy who wants to end his suffering . i see nothing wrong in it
 
I somehow, can't understand, how anyone, can have, a right to die ?

Earlier i tried to think of examples in the animal world where suicide happens. It seems so counter evolutionary but then i thought of honey bees. It's said that a bee dies soon after it stings. Thats the way it works for the benefit of the hive as a whole. Taking one's self out for the team. Not too different to a kamikaze or suicide bomber.

But this involves 'a' cause.

There have been cases of cattle jumping off a cliff when panicked but i attribute this to herd behavior, the animals involved are not aware of what they are doing. Or the case of roadkill where they just did not assess the situation correctly. Put it down to accidental death here.

Taking one's life willfully for no other benefit but for oneself ??


the difference between an animal and a human is that the human understands the concept of 'dignity'. an animal just wants to live by any means possible but a human being wants to live with dignity. so to make a human being live against his wish even when there is no chance of his leading a life of dignity any longer is, in my opinion more cruel than to actually 'kill him'

and yes don't tell me that we don't really kill a person when when we pull the plug on the man's life support because switching it on does not make the person 'alive' again. so yes life is taken away but still it is the more humane thing to do.


what i am undecided on is whether this should also apply to a newborn, born with severe disability??.. the above concept does look flawed when applied here because one can argue that that child would also not have a chance of living with dignity(say in the case of a child born with severe mental and physical disability)...


another reason why i think that Euthanasia should be legal is because just like in the case a soldier is allowed to (and even expected to when necessary) give up his life for his country(or in other words his society), a person who has no hope of recovering and is in a vegetative state should be allowed to die so that the resources in use to keep him alive can be used for the good of others in the society who have a chance of actually making use of it to get better.

oh and i am totally against suicides...
 
the difference between an animal and a human is that the human understands the concept of 'dignity'. an animal just wants to live by any means possible but a human being wants to live with dignity. so to make a human being live against his wish even when there is no chance of his leading a life of dignity any longer is, in my opinion more cruel than to actually 'kill him'


That's a fair point and vets do extend the courtesy to animals that are beyond recovery by putting them to sleep.

It's called being 'humane'.

By extension that's euthanasia in a nutshell.

what i am undecided on is whether this should also apply to a newborn, born with severe disability??.. the above concept does look flawed when applied here because one can argue that that child would also not have a chance of living with dignity(say in the case of a child born with severe mental and physical disability)...

The real reason behind this is that, it puts an intolerable strain on the parents.....and is thus the justification given for abortion.

The child is 'sacrificed' for the parents...course, that's never how its phrased ;)
 
Let me comment on banda's views first. Allowing the person in a vegetative to die is fine only if he wants to die. Dignity, in this case as well as the severely disabled baby one, even if it is an issue, will only be a secondary one. Because, if that is not held to be the case, and we go down the
- vegetative state = undignified, therefore kill him, or
- he is using resources that might be put to better use elsewhere, therefore kill him,
that is a very slippery slope and we might just end up going down the twisted road of aggressive eugenics/ cleansing. So I think the operative phrase in his post is should be allowed to die.

Every one has different mental capabilities and hardship handling capacities. For example, I might question the value of living if I go blind by some twist of fate, for I cannot imagine living without sight. On the other end of the spectrum, you have someone like Dr. Stephen Hawking. Can you imagine living a life like that, completely paralyzed and tied down to a wheel chair, having to depend on outside help for nearly every bodily function? That is why the answer to the question of where and how to draw the line should always lie with the person whose life we are talking about, one way or the other. On the matter of death and dignity, I'll let the original Dr. Gregory House do the talking -
Rebecca: I just want to die with a little dignity.
House: There’s no such thing! Our bodies break down, sometimes when we’re 90, sometimes before we’re even born, but it always happens and there’s never any dignity in it. I don’t care if you can walk, see, wipe your own ass. It’s always ugly, always. [Pause] You can live with dignity, we can’t die with it.


The real reason behind this is that, it puts an intolerable strain on the parents.....and is thus the justification given for abortion.

The child is 'sacrificed' for the parents...course, that's never how its phrased ;)
You are mixing two issues here, the one of aborting a fetus (where the 'baby' is yet to be born, even though it acquires distinct human characteristics a few weeks after conception) and the one where it has been born. Despite what the pro-life campaign says, it is the mother who is carrying around a dead weight and till the baby does not come out, the mother's decision, and her life is paramount. If she wants to abort, even playfully (I don't think people are so flippant about such issues, but still), she should be allowed to do so. I will even go to the extent of excluding the father-to-be from the abort-or-not-to-abort decision making process because his 'contribution' to the process of conception doesn't endanger his life, and is part of history when the abortion question does come up.

Once the baby is born, however, if it is severely disabled, my view on the Terry Schiavo case applies and as the legal/ medical proxy, the parents have the full power to decide what they should do about the same (again, once the bonafides have been established).

Here, lets consider your argument of the baby being sacrificed (again, baby, not the fetus), for this question will come up in law when the bonafides of the case are being checked. What does sacrifice mean? Parents cannot handle the emotional strain? Financial one maybe? Even if either is the case, what is the law going to do about it? Throw the parents in jail and take care of the baby itself? In this case, the question of disability and how it affects the child will have to be answered by a panel of erudite physicians. We cannot have stupid bureaucrats manage the process. Once the doctors say no, the baby can live a reasonably nomal life, the parents have to pay the bills or do their parenting duties. Or they go to jail. If the answer is the other way round, the parents have the final call. They might still say no to euthanasia. There is a difference between killing a normal baby (when the parents deserve to go to jail) and going down the euthanasia road for a severely disabled one. And it is a very important one.

Let's look at this again because it seems to contradict itself.....

Let me put it this way - "Right to my life includes the right to my death by a method of my own choosing."

Whenever we speak of rights, it is in reference to a person's relationships with others. If I am Robinson Crusoe living alone on a desert island, the entire argument is irrelevant because I do not need to prove, disprove or assert anything. The island is mine. I can starve to death if I want to. Or eat a tonne of fish if I want to. When we live in a society with others, the question of rights becomes significant because, if that question is not decided, anybody might come and cut you to pieces just because he wants to, and no one would be able to say that that (sic) was wrong. So, the assertion of 'right to life' means no one has the right to take any one else's life. It does not mean that no one has the right to take any life. This is one of the biggest tests the constitution of a country and its upholders have to pass - does a person have a right to his own life, and therefore his own death?

Authorising an action based on what *may* happen in the future.....
....So that's why you already said, via a living will, some time ago, to do it!

Yes. If you do care about how you want to die, and do not want default medical methodologies to kick in, you have to be proactive in specifying what you want to be done in certain cases. DNR orders, living wills and similar options are available. If you did not think about it, then there is nobody to blame but you. In any case, I think the default action (case where patient has not left any instructions) should be pro life rather than pro death.


That's fair enough i guess providing, as you say, the 'bonafides' had been established....
Some details on regulation in a couple of countries here

Your argument is correct because we cannot play around with life. The dangers of people getting murdered are too great. So, a proper checks-and-balances system is required to keep things under control. This allows a person to maintain his right to life, and death, while weeding out the fraudulent cases of probable murder. And I don't think things will be too difficult. Wills have been a part of the legal system for centuries now and other than a few contests here and there, no one complains about the process, do they? So, if you want to die peacefully, just like you get life insurance, and make a will, you should also decide on how you want to die in advance and things might be easier later on.

The BBC portal offers a neat summary of most arguments and counter arguments. But people will always pick what they want.


..with you so far.

Contradiction :)

Think I have covered it in enough detail in the above paragraphs.


I'd put this down to 'for a cause' or a sacrifice :)

The benefit or value to be gained 'for others' from the action, outweighs the cost.

Still violating 'right to life' but its a trade-off in this case.

It is not a sacrifice. Sacrifice implies a loss. If he thinks he is losing in the bargain, he might as well run away. He is only taking that extreme step because he thinks that their (his family's) value to him exceeds his value for his own life. I won't trade in a car for a bicycle. Nether will any sane person trade in his life for an absolute stranger or for the life/ comfort of a bitchy wife whom he absolutely hates. You will only do that, as I said, when you win in the bargain.

Is pronouncing death-sentence on himself for wrong doing. Price to pay here. Choose your poison, the result is inevitable either way.

I am thinking more on the lines of non-acceptance of loss of freedom. Of course guilt can also be a motivator.

When there is no direct benefit 'to others', or there are no lethal consequences of inaction....
...In some ways i also think the decison not to legalise euthanasia or suicide is to prevent its misuse as a loophole to commit murder.
Death is the absolute end. And it is a certainty. What you do, when you attempt suicide is bring the event forward. As I said, it is not a thing to be taken lightly, and people don't. But there do exist some cases where you will choose to die rather than live. The case will be different for different people. And I say again that its genesis is the idea of value. A person who values his life above everything else will never do anything that even remotely threatens it.

If you look at suicide purely from your own perspective, other than avoidance of intolerable pain of some kind (terminal condition, torture, some other hardship), there is no sane reason why anyone would kill himself. For loner Robinson Crusoe, these might be the only reasons. For those who live in society, if they find things of value in society - love, friendship, wealth, joy, then surely they might also find something that might just make them give up their life.

Till we know the entire secret of how the human mind functions, the answer to this 'why' can only be provided by two theories - insanity and value. Other than these two, I cannot think of anything else.
 
Let me put it this way - "Right to my life includes the right to my death by a method of my own choosing."

How about if you say..

"Right to my life includes the right freedom to cause my death by a method of my own choosing."

One is safe from others cept one's self :D

To *not* be allowed to do so implies, loss of 'a' freedom.

But to exercise this particular freedom must surely mean loss of the right to life. correct ?

The right-to-die supercedes the right-to-life.

That's the contradiction i don't know how to resolve :)

Rights are usually cummulative and don't conflict with each other, the right to die negates the whole lot, its literally the poison pill.

Doesn't the right to life have to supercede the right-to-die since life always precedes death?

It does, but you are saying one always retains the option to exercise one's right to die. And when that time comes one has the freedom to do so. Taken to its logical conclusion, you are also arguing that the right to suicide is a freedom, that too for a person that is not mentally unstable and fully cognisant of the action.

hope i do not appear to be putting words in your mouth..



Whenever we speak of rights, it is in reference to a person's relationships with others. If I am Robinson Crusoe living alone on a desert island, the entire argument is irrelevant because I do not need to prove, disprove or assert anything. The island is mine. I can starve to death if I want to. Or eat a tonne of fish if I want to. When we live in a society with others, the question of rights becomes significant because, if that question is not decided, anybody might come and cut you to pieces just because he wants to, and no one would be able to say that that (sic) was wrong. So, the assertion of 'right to life' means no one has the right to take any one else's life. It does not mean that no one has the right to take any life. This is one of the biggest tests the constitution of a country and its upholders have to pass - does a person have a right to his own life, and therefore his own death?

by 'any' i mean any human life == anyone else's life, but if we include self then that entails loss of freedom.

And yes, in crusoe's case the argument is a moot one.

But with reference to others i think the contradiction remains because as you say rights only exist wrt to others, so right-to-die will negate right-to-life.

Getting into murkier philosophical territory :)

Given we don't get a say in how we come to life, would the right-to-life be inalienable, then ?

..but then i guess you say, do we have the right to our lives, at all :D

That the acid test to whether we do truly have the right-to-our-lives *must* entail the freedom even to destroy it at will ?


It is not a sacrifice. Sacrifice implies a loss. If he thinks he is losing in the bargain, he might as well run away. He is only taking that extreme step because he thinks that their (his family's) value to him exceeds his value for his own life. I won't trade in a car for a bicycle. Nether will any sane person trade in his life for an absolute stranger or for the life/ comfort of a bitchy wife whom he absolutely hates. You will only do that, as I said, when you win in the bargain.

Haha, agreed.
 
To *not* be allowed to do so implies, loss of 'a' freedom.

But to exercise this particular freedom must surely mean loss of the right to life. correct ?

The right-to-die supercedes the right-to-life.

That's the contradiction i don't know how to resolve :)

Rights are usually cummulative and don't conflict with each other, the right to die negates the whole lot, its literally the poison pill.

I think the point of apparent contradiction (in life and death) should be solved if we differentiate between 'life' and 'to live'. Life is a far superior concept as compared to just living because it adds the spice of quality to the state of being alive. You can be in prison and still be living but that is probably not what you mean when you talk about life. If you look at things from that perspective, life is the root and living, dying, and various other freedoms will come within its ambit and 'to live' and 'to die' will no longer contradict each other.

...you are saying one always retains the option to exercise one's right to die. And when that time comes one has the freedom to do so. Taken to its logical conclusion, you are also arguing that the right to suicide is a freedom, that too for a person that is not mentally unstable and fully cognisant of the action.

hope i do not appear to be putting words in your mouth..

Yes that is precisely what I am saying. What is contradictory, actually, is the present system wherein everyone (the state, in most cases) other than yourself can take your life.

by 'any' i mean any human life == anyone else's life, but if we include self then that entails loss of freedom.

And yes, in crusoe's case the argument is a moot one.

But with reference to others i think the contradiction remains because as you say rights only exist wrt to others, so right-to-die will negate right-to-life.

Getting into murkier philosophical territory :)

If you follow the above argument, since my being the cause of my own death does not result from rogue actions by a third party (which is what a right expressly forbids), even this contradiction disappears.

Given we don't get a say in how we come to life, would the right-to-life be inalienable, then ?

If we give credence to this argument, then multi-generational slavery or bonded labour would not be immoral or illegal, would it?

..but then i guess you say, do we have the right to our lives, at all :D

That the acid test to whether we do truly have the right-to-our-lives *must* entail the freedom even to destroy it at will ?

Freedom is the foundation on which every right stands. So, as long as one person's actions do not directly inconvenience or endanger someone else's life, there is no moral or legal foundation to ban euthanasia or suicide.

The moment you place restrictions on a person's right to life, you lose the right to take the moral or legal higher ground, for, just like every law passed by the state which is ultra vires the constitution is deemed illegal, people are not bound by any law or constitution that is ultra vires the concept of natural law, of which freedom is an unalienable part. This argument won't prevent countries with a tendency to enact malicious laws from throwing you in jail if you attempt such a thing, but you can sleep sound knowing that you have done no wrong.
 
Back