Red Terror!

  • Thread starter Thread starter SVK
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 26
  • Views Views 5,547
So how did INC manage to do it in Andhra ?How long have Chattisgarh & Jharkhand been with the BJP.
 
Do not cite the andhra example. It was a psy-ops followed by a brute force clampdown. Though i feel the normalcy could be temporary.
 
Do not cite the andhra example. It was a psy-ops followed by a brute force clampdown.
hmm, that would be the simple explanation. The more detailed one is that the state took back control of its writ by suporting the cops at the local level and then allowing the people to choose between the state or the naxals. That's how you tackle an insurgency in short.

So I would say for the short term, that is exactly what needs to be done given it has succeeded.

Though i feel the normalcy could be temporary.
Quite likely as they have yet to introduce any land reform.
 
hmm, that would be the simple explanation. The more detailed one is that the state took back control of its writ by suporting the cops at the local level and then allowing the people to choose between the state or the naxals. That's how you tackle an insurgency in short.

Their govt was willing to do it, and perhaps they managed to do it. What about other state govt who are not doing anything? and states like Jharkhand which dont have any govt :)
So centre should come up with common plan for all states, so this problem can be tackled in combined manner.
 
All the Centre can do is send more CPRF troops. Who will get slaugthered as there is zero intel on the naxals in these areas.How to get that intel ?Ppl from those areas need to choose between the state & the naxals. If the state is absent then they will always choose the naxals because otherwise they will be in trouble. Unless the states themselves strengthen the local cops in those areas the ppl will not feel protected by the state at all.Now do you see how limited the centre's contribution is ?Plans to deal with naxals, in the jungle cannot be put together by some type sitting in Delhi, this is a dynamic situation.As i've said earlier until these states decide to tackle this problem the centre is at best a distressed observer.BJP is just passing the buck.
 
blrp do you support using military against the naxals
Depends on the role, support, training, use of drones for intel, yes.

Bombing like your clip indicates, most defnitely not. That would be like using a sledgehammer to catch a fly, it would be a naxal PR windfall and entrench their position even more.

also no common law country or so called liberal democracy has ever used military against its own people.
I've read a better argument than that, and set a precedent for a common law country.

Ppl were suggesting that we've already used the military in Punjab, Kashmir & some of the 7 sisters so why not also with the naxals. But the differrence with the naxals is there is no foreign element involved at all.

The Aizawl clip is interesting, I wonder what the background behind it was.

when the Mizo National Front (MNF), in a surprise attack, overran practically the whole of Mizoram, including Aizawl, its capital. To dislodge the MNF insurgents from Aizawl, air strikes by the Air Force of a limited duration were ordered.

The Armed Forces should be used ONLY in a desperate ground situation. The situation in the Maoist-controlled areas is serious, but not desperate.
source
 
we should rather have this
Posse Comitatus Act - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Insurrection Act - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

using troops against our own people means that the govt is the enemy.
rather than implementing mine royalties to the tribals,bringing back the right to private property we are using eye for an eye.
the preamble starts with we the people

more

Trinamool MP warns government against the use of army to fight Maoists
Trinamool Congress MP Kabir Suman has said that if Central government uses army against the Maoists, it could be one short of a war.
Talking to reporters here on Wednesday, Suman said: "If the government deploys the army then they will see what a war is. I have that faith in the people of the country."
He termed the Maoists as "true patriots" fighting to prevent capture of tribal lands and destruction of culture by corporate houses with the help of the government.





well i dont think that naxals are true patriots but we should not use army.use the solution that i have presented coupled with infrastructure(use the damm black money swiss accounts which mr ram jetmalani says the members of the upa also have,wiki says sonia ji has $2 billion )



common sense
 
using troops against our own people means that the govt is the enemy.
The key difference is the degree of involvement.

rather than implementing mine royalties to the tribals,bringing back the right to private property we are using eye for an eye.
This is a major problem that nobody seems to want to address.


Trinamool MP warns government against the use of army to fight Maoists
Trinamool Congress MP Kabir Suman has said that if Central government uses army against the Maoists, it could be one short of a war.
Talking to reporters here on Wednesday, Suman said: "If the government deploys the army then they will see what a war is. I have that faith in the people of the country."
He termed the Maoists as "true patriots" fighting to prevent capture of tribal lands and destruction of culture by corporate houses with the help of the government.
That there should indicate what progress Bengal is making wrt to this issue. Trinamool evidently require naxal support to win elections. Same with Soren in Jharkhand.


.use the solution that i have presented coupled with infrastructure
I have not understood what your solution entails, can you summarise ?
 
Some good points by EN Rammohan
After the train tragedy in Bengal, there is renewed talk of bringing on the army and air force in the fight against the Maoists. What is your view on this?

I think it would be a terrible mistake. The more you try to deal with this issue through military options, the more it will spread and grow in strength.

You were asked by the Home Ministry to investigate the recent Maoist ambush of CRPF jawans in Dantewada. The government obviously thinks well of your judgement, track record and integrity. So how do you read the Maoist crisis facing the country today?
I think it is first and foremost an issue of social justice. I first came across the problem when I was posted in Hyderabad in the 1980s as DIG, CBI. My batchmate Ajay Deora was DG, Intelligence and he was struggling to control things. I am from the Assam cadre and have handled insurgencies before. I was in the Indo-Tibetan Border Police, which was set up with the objective of fighting behind enemy lines, so we have all been trained in guerrilla warfare. Insurgencies are my abiding interest.

Most of the Maoist leadership comes from Andhra. Why do you think this is the case?
From what I saw in Andhra the primary problem is land. The upper castes have been exploiting tribals and Scheduled Castes (SCs) for generations. Before Independence there was no land ceiling, so the upper castes had huge land holdings that often ran into over a 1,000 acres, while the SCs and tribals had no land, or very small holdings. Yet even these small holdings were taken over forcibly by the upper castes who would buy their produce then fudge the accounts, to keep them indebted. The tribals were turned into tenant farmers who had to till the land but give 2/3rd of the produce to the upper castes. It is against this backdrop in 1946 that the CPI first started working in the Telangana areas. They would collect a group of tribals with bows and arrows, surround an upper caste granary and distribute the grain. Then they would tell the landowner that from now on 2/3rds would go to the tillers, 1/3rd to the landowner. Of course the landowners would complain to the police who would round up the locals and arrest and beat them.

After Independence, land ceiling laws were legislated but they were never implemented in Andhra. In 1989, when the government changed, I told my friend Deora, let’s go meet the Revenue Minister. I told the minister, you’ll never be able to solve this problem. He was very unhappy with the way I spoke and said, why not? I told him if you want to stub out this movement, impose land ceiling. He said, that’s impossible, we can never do that. He gave the example of Sudhakar Rao, one of his colleagues from Adilabad. That fellow has got 1,100 acres, he said, and he won’t be willing to part with even one.
The risk of a counter-action now is that our forces can go mad. They’ll seek
revenge for their 76 mates killed

So the caste structure in Andhra Pradesh is such. There are many police stations even today where a Scheduled Caste will not dare to file an FIR — it just won’t be registered or investigated. Then of course, the women were being misused. Labourers on a farm had to offer their bride on the first night to the landlord. This is reflected even in the folk songs of the Adivasis. There is no hope for women in this country, they sing. So unless these wrongs are righted, how are you expecting a solution to this problem? There can be no military solution to this problem.

The media has gone hoarse speaking of them as terrorists. Are you comfortable with this description?
You see everyone talks about the Naxalites but very few people understand there are two parts to this. There are the Adivasis and Scheduled Castes at the lowest strata. Then there are the leaders from the CPI, CPI Marxist-Leninist and now CPI-Maoist. These are all communists and 99 percent of them are upper caste. But because of their political philosophy they have no caste and are lending a hand to the poor. Now they have a political agenda and their objective is to come to power in this country. I don’t want to live in a Maoist State but if we continue with our current arrogance, that’s exactly what will happen. There will be great upheaval in society. Go to communist countries like Russia or China. If you look at all the top class people there now — men like Kruschev — you’ll see everyone in power today were all peasants once, and the upper class people have all disappeared somewhere. In India also, there will be a complete upheaval in society. So I don’t see why we are so hesitant to rectify our course and address issues of social justice.

You have spoken of Andhra. How do you read Chhattisgarh?

In Chhattisgarh, it’s mostly to do with rights over forests. The Adivasis have been pushed into the forests over thousands of years by caste domination, and are now almost entirely confined to it. They have no land and can only collect forest produce. But they still have to sell it and when they come out of the forest to the market place, they have to find a buyer. And who’s the buyer? The Vaishya trader. At the root of this trouble, I say, is this trio — the wily Brahmin, the arrogant Kshatriya, the avaricious Vaishya. Chidambaram, incidentally, is a Vaishya. These three social groups have been trampling on these people for centuries, so why blame them if the CPI has lent a hand? They help the poor by inspecting the Vaishya’s books and ensuring tribals get a correct price. You should investigate the tendu leaf trade — I am told the money from that reaches politicians in Delhi, while the poor man who picks the leaf gets nothing.

The point is, in any insurgency, people take to guns because they feel they have no choice. In this case, the tribals are being taught by the Maoists to fight for their rights. And in Marxist teaching, guerrilla warfare is one of the subjects. All these escalating incidents, the ambushes etc, is designed to get hold of weapons. But the risk of a counter-action now is that our forces can go beserk. They will say we’ve lost 76 people and they will just shoot anyone, they’ll kill everybody, even innocent people, unless there is a very strong leadership to keep them in control. And I am afraid that leadership does not exist. This is something the government must understand.

So what do you see as solutions? And what do you think is holding up those solutions?
There are two acts pending in Parliament — one is to do with land acquisition, the other is to do with forest rights. But the interesting thing is, minerals have been found in these forests and for the party in power, this is a big bonanza. If you sign a MOU worth millions of dollars for excavating minerals, a percentage of it will go to your Swiss Bank account. The poor man in the forest is conveniently forgotten. In Bihar, the Bhumihars openly say, “Hamare patte hum billi aur kutte ke naam pe lagate hain (We list our land titles in the names of our cats and dogs)”. How long can such a situation continue without protest? And you say you want to bring in the army? Why don’t you look inwards and rectify this? If the government has any sense in its head, it will, otherwise it will be a terrible situation. It will be a disaster.


Full :
Tehelka - India's Independent Weekly News Magazine
 
Back