What should the constitution be based on ?

  • Thread starter Thread starter blr_p
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 8
  • Views Views 1,432

blr_p

Regulars
Messages
3,886
Location
NA
ISP
Airtel 256k ultd
I strongly believe that India is Hindu country (Hindustan) and its constitution should based on Hinduism (as I described)


This is an interesting question, and might deserve its own topic so as not to disturb the one i pulled it from.

Anyone know what the constitution is based on currently ?

At first thought the thing that comes to my mind is "universal rights of man".

SO if we were to do what you want, would that reduce or expand freedoms contained within ?
 
I am not that scholar in the topic, so I cannot immediately reply on what/how it should be. I will need to do some study first.But my idea of Hinduism/Hindutva is what was followed by Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj (or even Akbar), in which this kings followed Hindutva. But all other religions had equal rights, all religions were treated equally. Besides Hindutva is believed to be most tolerant religion, as they have never attacked any region/country for sake of religion, nor have any individual/community/group converted to Hindu forcibly/bribe/etc methods. (Now this doesn't mean other religions are evil).About our constitution, I think they claim it to be secular, but it is still religious based, as still in courts, person is asked to take oath on religious book. Then we have marriage acts based on religions. So some religious belief were followed while preparing constitution.
 
Exactly, the constitution only defines the secular bits. The personal comes under relgious law where applicable.
 
India is a predominantly Hindu country, that doesn't mean the minority cultures should be treated any less equals. The constitution as it stands now seems to be reasonable, for a diverse country giving one culture more importance over another is just plain dangerous.
 
That was my initial impression as well, so lets wait for SVK to come back with more details.
 
person is asked to take oath on religious book.
No they aren't! Don't believe what you see in movies!!! (e.g. there is no gavel that the judge beats, and there is no "order, order!").
Then we have marriage acts based on religions. So some religious belief were followed while preparing constitution.
That's true. Personal law (relating to marriage, divorce, inheritance etc.) is based on religion as far as it recognizes that different communities have different customs etc. BUT the Constitution does speak of gradually adopting a uniform civil code, i.e. personal law that is secular and uniform for all Indians regardless of religion. For better or for worse, there is no political (or social) will to head in that direction. It's similar to the reservation / quota issue - the Constitution provided for it as a temporary transitory method to bring all sections to a level playing field, and then for it to be phased out once that was achieved - but now it has created so many vested interests, and with vote bank politics, it's almost become a permanent feature.
 
https://broadband.forum/politics/43406-should-we-have-presidential-system/

suggestions
https://broadband.forum/politics/43406-should-we-have-presidential-system/3/


us constitution

[ame="[media=youtube]aLx8YLCxQEA[/media] - Separation of Church & State: Keep your gods hands off....[/ame]

[ame="[media=youtube]WqLfKE4xTts[/media] - Separation of Church and State[/ame]

[URL="https://www.youtube.com/watch?gl=IN&hl=en-GB&v=jEYjhHIH-P8"]YouTube - God and the United States Constitution[/URL]

btw founding fathers on USA were deists.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Umm, warthog, presdential or not has already been covered in this thread.

So wrt to this topic its a mere detail not the foundation a constitution is based.
 
Back