Google vs. Oracle

motorola is of course not going to signup any deals. why? two reasons. google owns them now and signing a deal would mean that google knowingly infringed on patents. motorola is THE oldest mobile phone company in the world i think. and they should have enough patents to take on Microsoft. motorola mobility is essentially going to be google. and google is buying tons of patents from ibm and other sources. google is working hard on ensuring that they are ready for any potential lawsuit from microsoft which would happen in the future. motorola is already involved in multiple lawsuits with Apple. and they are doing pretty ok against them. microsoft however now have more tools in their arsenals as they have a license sharing deal with Nokia. and as the rumors go, they are very much likely to expand their partnership with nokia. and this could include acquiring their smartphone division.
 
When the company initially demanded $6.1 billion from Google in recompense for alleged violations of its Java patents, Alsup laughed that figure out of court and suggested $100 million might be closer to the mark. Ellison's crew then came back with a revised claim of $2 billion, which we just knew would lead to another smackdown. Well, here it is: the judge has now cancelled the latest trial date (which had been scheduled for March) and refused to set a new one until the claimant stops using "improper methodologies" for assessing damages, which are "obviously calculated to reach stratospheric numbers."

Judge attacks Oracle's 'stratospheric' damages claim against Google, postpones trial -- Engadget

This judge is pretty sane. I wonder how come he is still a judge.
 
I am not quite in favour of this judge. If he has his way, he would rather have Oracle pay Google just because he loves Google. So far he has shown almost negligible interest in this case, scrapping most of Oracle's claims without even bothering to go through them, and trying to masquerade as messiah of open technology
 
Do these companies actually show the break up of how much they spend behind getting patents & how much they spend behind product development?Also, do they report how much they earn from patent lawsuits & how much from their ACTUAL BUSINESSES??I guess, the latter part of both would be a smaller component, looking at the amount of patent lawsuits these days.
 
getting patents is part of the R&D operations. microsoft, Apple etc etc are some of the biggest spenders on R&D. the concept behind patents is not evil of course. but the ability to patent shit like slide to unlock is absurd. xerox originally invented the concept of GUI and Mouse... if they had patented it and used these patents to target companies like apple... the personal computing world would have been totally different today.
 
^ Part of the reason they couldn't do that was this practice wasn't in place in those days. IINM, this started sometime early 90s.
 
And the reason for that cud be that the companies in those days did their MAIN BUSINESS REALLY WELL, which is why they didnt have time for nit-picking on their competitors! :p :D
 
In a way, yes, there was a lot of monopoly in those days as most technology we use today was in nascent stages
 
Oracle Corp will ask a jury next week to find that Google Inc stole its intellectual property to make Android software in a trial that a federal judge called the "World Series of IP cases."

Oracle, the database maker seeking to wring profit from its $7.4 billion 2010 acquisition of Sun Microsystems Inc (JAVA), is seeking $1 billion in damages and an injunction to block Android software that allegedly infringes patents it owns through Sun. Google, whose Android software is running on more than 150 million devices, denies any infringement and says the Oracle- owned technology it used isn't covered by copyright.

"This is the World Series of IP cases," US District Judge William Alsup , who will preside over the trial in San Francisco, told lawyers for both companies March 28. "Only one winner comes out of the World Series."

The eight-week trial is scheduled to begin April 16 with jury selection. Oracle alleges that Google copied parts of the Java programming language
platform when designing the Android operating system without taking a license. The arrangement and structure of 37 application programming interfaces, or APIs -- tools used for building software applications -- Google used are original expressions that are copyrightable, Oracle's attorneys have said.



'Art, not a science'

"We're talking about the design of the libraries by designers who are designing something that is an art, not a science, and that is creative," Oracle lawyer Michael Jacobs said in a March 28 court hearing.

More than 97 per cent of Android phones active in the past two weeks contain copied code, Oracle said in an April 5 court filing. An injunction is needed to stop Google from distributing infringing products to phone makers, the
Redwood City
, California-based company said. Alsup would decide after the trial whether an injunction is warranted if the jury finds Google infringed.

Settlement talks held April 2 and in September failed to resolve the lawsuit.

Developed by Sun in the mid-1990s, Java lets developers write programs that work across different operating systems and on a variety of computers. It formed a key building block of the Web and is widely used in business applications. The software also runs on billions of mobile devices.



Oracle seeks ban on Android - The Times of India
 
Jealousy can drive companies to any extent really. They must be thinking that how the hell such stuff can be distributed open source! The profit hungry corporates are always after those who are open source......be it Apple and Oracle doing nit picking against Google, or be it Microsoft against Google or other open source desktop OSes.
 
Back