How secure are EVMs?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Sushubh
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 299
  • Views Views 27,381
it.in usa they are off worse but there individual states decide whether to use e voting or paper.paper is the best and more accountable.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
People are corrupt and capable of fraud, not objects and items. EVMs are no more secure than paper ballots.
 
heh. if they had any control, why would they continue to lose in gujarat and up? :)
 
Row over EVMs goes to court - Indian Express
Around 80 candidates who lost in the Pune and Pimpri-Chinchwad municipal elections have filed elections petitions in the court alleging tampering of electronic voting machines (EVM), distribution of money by winning candidates and faulty verification of caste certificates. Among the prominent candidates who have filed these petitions include Shyam Deshpande, Shashikala Mengde, Raja Tungatkar, Sangeeta Tiwari, Dilip Umbarkar, Ram Sambhaji Patre versus Jagdish Shetty and others.
A total of 35 candidates from Pimpri-Chinchwad filed the petition in civil court (senior division) Pune, while about 45 candidates from Pune filed petitions in the small causes court, Pune.


Pune polls: Defeated candidates file complaint against ‘defective’ EVM - Mumbai - DNA
Damodar Namdeo Kumbare and Shyam Deshpande, who faced defeat in the Pune Municipal Corporation elections in panel number 28, have complained to the police suspecting of EVM tampering.
The duo submitted their complaint to police commissioner, deputy commissioner of police (cyber crime cell) and police inspector (cyber crime cell) through lawyer SK Jain. However, the police are yet to file a case.
Jain said, “We will file a petition in court, if we don’t get a response to police complaint by Monday.”
The plaint alleged that when a mock poll demo was given by election officials at Yashwantrao Chavan Auditorium on February 13, all EVMs were not shown to the candidates. The duo reported that when Kumbare’s brother Shivaji voted, the indicator did not glow and when he orally complained to the booth’s election officer, the official said that the machine is in proper condition and his vote will be registered. A complaint against EVMs was made to the returning officer after the counting of votes, but those machines are yet to be tested, the duo alleged.


Should we trust EVMs for voting, or go back to old method of Ballot papers???
 
Two topics here - A) Defective EVMs B)MalpracticeDefective EVMs are a concern & need to be checked & replaced.Malpractise, they are talking about device being "tampered". If so, someone who is part of the security of EVMs must be involved... Similarly the people involved in security of ballot papers could be again be "involved" or alleged to be involved in doing the same thing :|
 
Back