Section-49-O | NOTA

  • Thread starter Thread starter blr_p
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 87
  • Views Views 35,928
my dad decided to get voter ID cards for all of us in the family the regular official way without using any connections. it has been one month. we are still filling forms. everytime we submit the form, the officials return them finding something or the other. :D i really have no desire to vote for anyone. ever. so well. i do not want voting to be made compulsory.
 
Will not make any difference on the election results! Only more selective harassing of innocent non-voters."As noted in the wiki entry by Anupam Saraph, EC had KNOWN the results 10 days before the counting (that is on 6th May when the counting date was 16th May) and in the case of over 100 candidates, the spreadsheets maintained by EC on 6 May tallied with the final results. How did this happen?"Votes (to be) polled by 9000 odd candidates was available in the excel sheet maintained in the EC official website even before the last phase of polling. The columns were removed subsequently. The original list was downloaded by a Pune based techie. Like all issues, this also died down after a few reports in the press and forums.How to make the system tamper proof?
 
make it all online! get it audited by a recognized body? i dont care. we are going to be ruled by !@#$%$%^ all our lives.
 
Will not make any difference on the election results! Only more selective harassing of innocent non-voters.

Well if there is close to 90% turnout, in the example above instead of 15% they will need 25% more votes. Its an improvement over the current.


"As noted in the wiki entry by Anupam Saraph, EC had KNOWN the results 10 days before the counting (that is on 6th May when the counting date was 16th May) and in the case of over 100 candidates, the spreadsheets maintained by EC on 6 May tallied with the final results. How did this happen?"

Where is the source you quote this from ?
 
good articel
http://www.philosophyblog.com.au/some-arguments-for-and-against-compulsory-voting/


If we are free then we are free to choose to vote or not.
australia dosent even have bill of rights,they have a privilege.


-- that compulsory voting is an undemocratic infringement on liberty -- any force is prima facie undesirable. You're for practical purposes compelled to do a number of things -- including being present at a polling booth (instead of going to the beach or earning money), spending time considering the various issues and policies and candidates (if you don't want to make an irrational decision), being involved in a political group, and becoming responsible for various chains of event (what if I vote Labor in, and they go on to do this or that evil deed -- am I blameworthy?);

-- that you might have some reasonable reason (perhaps religious or moral) for not voting (see below); and society should encourage more such people of conscience;

-- that it's bad for society if idiots and the uninterested are compelled to vote -- bad choices get made, or bad politics are encouraged (for instance, the political process might become more populist or superficial, or turn more into a battle of character than of policy);

-- that compulsory voting increases the number of donkey or reverse donkey or otherwise random votes, and therefore delegitimizes government;

-- that it can change the political process in ways that some deem undesirable (for instance, parties may spend more time targeting swinging voters than their base supporters, the policies of parties may evolve to become centrist and not meaningfully differentiated -- some have claimed that right and left have already coalesced --, and, at the most extreme, parties could be induced to spend much more in marginal than in safe electorates);

-- that it can give rise to a false veneer of legitimacy, and cover up problems of voter apathy and discontent;

-- that, in some societies, it's dangerous to vote (for instance, Wikipedia mentions that the Shining Path group in Peru has threatened voters);

-- that it may cause backlash (in terms of voter discontent and informal voting) if it's perceived as oppressive;

-- that the cost of it (mobile voting booths, etc) can be substantial, especially for poorer countries;

-- that a benefit of a voluntary system is that political parties would have to work harder and remain closer to their electorate in order to motivate people to vote in the first place.
 
If we are free then we are free to choose to vote or not.
australia dosent even have bill of rights,they have a privilege.


-- that compulsory voting is an undemocratic infringement on liberty --

-- that you might have some reasonable reason (perhaps religious or moral) for not voting (see below); and society should encourage more such people of conscience;

In principle these arguments are fine.



-- that it's bad for society if idiots and the uninterested are compelled to vote
-- that compulsory voting increases the number of donkey or reverse donkey or otherwise random votes, and therefore delegitimizes government;


This is no more than 1-2% so its negligible.

-- that it can change the political process in ways that some deem undesirable (for instance, parties may spend more time targeting swinging voters than their base supporters, the policies of parties may evolve to become centrist and not meaningfully differentiated -- some have claimed that right and left have already coalesced --, and, at the most extreme, parties could be induced to spend much more in marginal than in safe electorates);

They are already doing this as indicated in my first post. The idea is to force them to work harder. So yes they will do the same but will have to cover a larger population which is the idea.

-- that it can give rise to a false veneer of legitimacy, and cover up problems of voter apathy and discontent;

Less false than currently :)

-- that, in some societies, it's dangerous to vote (for instance, Wikipedia mentions that the Shining Path group in Peru has threatened voters);

See naxalites or Kashmir, state has the resources to deal with it.

-- that it may cause backlash (in terms of voter discontent and informal voting) if it's perceived as oppressive;

Yes to a certain extent.

-- that the cost of it (mobile voting booths, etc) can be substantial, especially for poorer countries;

Has to be weighed against potential gains. The whole exercise of voting costs money but its deemed better than no elections at all in the long run :)

-- that a benefit of a voluntary system is that political parties would have to work harder and remain closer to their electorate in order to motivate people to vote in the first place.

No, i think its the opposite as is currently and in most countries that have voluntary voting. The media glosses it over and hails it as mandate and whatnot but its not the case.

Discussing it with a friend and was surprised to hear the term 'benevolent dictatorship' being used.

Yes, in reference to us and by extension to all countries with low turnouts & voluntary voting. Because who gets to stay or enter office is determined by a small minority.
 
and thats why i hate democracy.
We should have indirect elections ,hell even the constitution review committee recommended indirect election in lok sabha and even for the PM.
thats why i love republic aka rule of law and not the rule of majority.

even more arguments
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compulsory_voting#Arguments_against

ps:blr you should join politics or create your NGO.YOu are every learned and knowledgeable
 
and thats why i hate democracy.
We should have indirect elections ,hell even the constitution review committee recommended indirect election in lok sabha and even for the PM.
thats why i love republic aka rule of law and not the rule of majority.

We already have indirect voting, after all we dont pick the PM.

And why do you say we are not a republic ?

The arguments against in the wiki are fine too, why impose on the ppl and them not participating as an indictment on the system, hence the 49-O.

I myself am in two minds over this idea as the only ratoinale for compulsory voting is that it has more representation than the current system.

But if it has to outlaw non-participation then its causing contradictions with freedom itself.

In a way its saying the state is more important than the individual. This applies in some cases but not in others.
 
with the biometric card under development... we should be allowed to cast our vote online using some unique identification from that card.
 
Back