Section-49-O | NOTA

  • Thread starter Thread starter blr_p
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 87
  • Views Views 35,928
make it all online! get it audited by a recognized body?

i dont care. we are going to be ruled by !@#$%$%^ all our lives.

Why vote then?
 
with the biometric card under development... we should be allowed to cast our vote online using some unique identification from that card.

Right.
 
@blr_p: There was sporadic reporting in the press and actively in forums; but, as loke other issues, was given a unknown burial.

*Tracking the elections - Government Wiki *

You might be interested to hear that Dr Anupam Saraph (CIO of Pune, India,
and an adviser to the UN and the Asian Development Society) and Professor
Madhav Nalapat (Director of the Department of Manipal University, India, as
well as a UNESCO Peace Chair holder, Madhav Das Nalapat - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia)
accidentally discovered files on an official Indian government website that
seemed to have voting result numbers long before votes were actually cast.

On May 6th, while looking for routine, publicly available, candidate data
during the election, a detailed Excel file of votes polled results for every
candidate in India was found on the official website of the Election
Commission of India (Candidate Details).
That was 9 days before the final votes were cast on May 15. And, even so,
the Election Commission was not supposed to have access to votes cast data
until May 16, when official counting was to be done.

On May 7 and 11, the Excel file was downloaded again from the Election
Commission site. The numbers of votes cast for some candidates changed in
each version of the file. In the version of the file downloaded on the last
day before the official counting, May 15th, the votes cast results column
was blank.

The downloaded files can be found here (the votes cast numbers are in Column
N “votespolled”): Tracking the elections - Government Wiki

When news of the files started to spread, the Election Commission closed its
site from May 23 to 25. It was back up on the 25th but, until the 29th, you
couldn’t download the file anymore. You can now, but the votes cast data for
each candidate is gone (you can just see who won) even though now, two weeks
after the election, is when that data should be available.

The implications are unsettling.
May 30, 2009...6:13 am EVM Fixing

The results of recent Indian elections have taken everyone by surprise. They
are really bizzare. There is something rotten going on. How did Congress and
the Western countries which support it slyly managed to get these dream
results? Does the possibility of EVM (electronic voting machines) rigging
exist?

Why were the Congress courtiers hell-bent on getting Navin Chawla to head
the Election Commission? What role could this despicable doormat of 10
Janpath have possibly played? EVMs hold the key to this mystery.
Interestingly EVMs are thoroughly discredited the world over because they
are prone to manipulation. One agency has even called them a “threat to
national security.”

All non-Congress parties in India would do well to launch a campaign to ban
the use of EVMs. Or at least ensure that the EVM prints a ballot that is
then dropped into a box for later counting and tallying the results with the
EVMs. Strange things are possible with the use of EVMs. The most bizzare of
these being the last-minute win of Chidambaram when he was trailing the
other candidate the whole day in counting. Seems like Congress courtiers are
allying with some foreign intelligence agencies to rule India in a “you
scratch my back, I scratch yours” pact.

EVM Fixing Indian Realist
 
Will not make any difference on the election results! Only more selective harassing of innocent non-voters.

You make it sound like elections were rigged in many places :)

Its possible in a few places like how chidambaram, initially lost and subsequently won. My tamil friends think Karunanidhi sacrificed a pawn for this and do not believe he won at all. But i think its conspiracy theory to claim such :)

EVMs are not the problem here if anything they are virtually tamper proof and the comparison with other countires EVMs is not appropriate.

Yes, votes will continue to be bought like always and everywhere but stuffing ballot boxes is no longer an option. And this is the MAJOR reason why ppl would like to go back to paper, the links posted here are all crap!

When you think about it maybe you vote on principles & ideals but a poorer person who does not think these ideals will put food on the table only moves if promised something more concrete. There is not much difference here as both are voting based on a promise and future expectation.

So instead of getting 15% like in the example given earlier they need 30%.

A few % points more in a country of 100s of millions voters. Just imagine how many more ppl they need to buy.
 
1. EVMs must be made tamper proof- nothing will be tamper proof if the govt/EC wants to influence results. Definite no paper ballots; it is also not tamper proof.2. Compulsory voting will be unenforceable law; will be used only to harass people and potential misuse.3. In the recent TN elections, it was reported that DMK agents were keeping a list of people who were given cash, and was cancelling the names of those who voted. Warning was given to those to who received money but reluctant to vote. In many booths there was heavy voting after regular voting hours - large no. turned up around 6 pm.
 
1. EVMs must be made tamper proof- nothing will be tamper proof if the govt/EC wants to influence results. Definite no paper ballots; it is also not tamper proof.

Our EVMs are tamper proof :)

Pls take the time to go through all the points mentioned there and don't fall for half baked theories.

Read the Indiresan Expert Committee Report on EVM if you want to know all techincal ways to hack EVMs and the counter-measures employed.

Ain't possible on a technical level so have to use social engineering.

Buying votes, ppls names mysteriously dissapearing on the voting list etc.

2. Compulsory voting will be unenforceable law; will be used only to harass people and potential misuse.

Harrassment is certainly there. But enforcement is a matter of checking who voted and who did not. Those that did not pay a penalty.

Now if names go missing what happens :)

If you don't vote and your name goes missing do you have to pay a fine or not ?

Question arises as to why you did not vote and then you give the explanation that name was absent and you DID try to vote. Won't questions be directed at the booth level as to why this happened.


3. In the recent TN elections, it was reported that DMK agents were keeping a list of people who were given cash, and was cancelling the names of those who voted. Warning was given to those to who received money but reluctant to vote. In many booths there was heavy voting after regular voting hours - large no. turned up around 6 pm.

These should have been brought to the attention of the EC. Why was no charge filed ?

Its all very good to state things much after the fact but I find if charges were not filed in a timely fashion then the case is somehow weak.

Large numbers showing up isn't technically a problem as the EVMs wil only record so many votes for a given time period.
 
here yo goe voting=pain in the assalso tech_enthu is right.How the hell all the candidates voting data result was on the website 9 days before the actual result?did Madhav Nalapat save the xls file?also a awesome docu by HBO(so its not conspiracy ok) about e voting.bush stole the elections in 2000 thanks to florida and in 2004 thanks to ohio HACKING DEMOCRACYhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?gl=IN&hl=en-GB&v=iVlZTWH7u8w&fmt=18
 
Why vote then?

i have never voted in my life.

i really do not accept the concept that one vote can do magic. blah.

as tata guy said. i am sleeping. i like sleeping.
 
also tech_enthu is right.How the hell all the candidates voting data result was on the website 9 days before the actual result?did Madhav Nalapat save the xls file?

Umm no he is not right, because the counter is very simple.

Why is this bit of news on some blog and not in front of the EC :)

The conclusion can only be is that it might be rubbished and thrown out.

Prove the point, in court!

also a awesome docu by HBO(so its not conspiracy ok) about e voting.


Votes are stolen at each election, i'm not going to contest that, names go missing on voter lists, he who has the most arrack to dish out, TVs, cash etc can & does buy votes.

This will happen regardless of EVMs or not.

The point with increasing the number of votes is that it becomes more expensive to pull these off. It does not make them impossible.

i really do not accept the concept that one vote can do magic. blah.

The same would apply here again but to a lesser extent.

I'm not decided yet on whether one can impose this yet. There has to be sound reasoning to do so :)
 
Back