2G Scam

  • Thread starter Thread starter Sahyadri
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 403
  • Views Views 109,040
A Raja is a curious mix of retardation and corruption . The issue is MTNL and BSNL's inept management , who are so hopeless that they can fail absolutely any kind of technology head start that you provide them with . MTNL is still better , BSNL's losses are mounting by the day , they will have to ultimately privatise it .
Makes you wonder if that is the plan in the end. Then again looking at the trends of state telecoms in various countries that appears to be the general trend, spin off into private entities.

Mixed feelings about this, if it happens too soon, deprived areas will lose out as there is no profit motive to serve them. If it happens after there is a basic infrastructure in place then unless there is a vigilant & empowered watchdog we end up with a cartel.

TRAI is supposed to be such a watchdog, yet I do not find many ppl here trumpeting about their success at all. It would not be too far to say that TRAI has been ineffective, tho i'm not sure if thats because this forum tends to be more biased towards wired broadband or not.
 
BSNL is a government company; so money trnsfer is from one pocket to another.Pitroda committee has recommended part privatisation of BSNL. His report will soon be discussed/ implemented. BSNL gets free spectrum and after a month or so will sell its shares/ assets to raja-friendly private investors. So all benefit, directly or indirectly.
 
haha. consumers are not the kings. anywhere. :D unless of course you live in finland. :P
 
When they say that A Raja (or whoever) stole 170000 crore rupees in the 2G scam... I assume they do not mean that he made that much money from the scam right. this amount is something they believe the indian government could have made from selling the 2G spectrum but they did not. So, basically this is just a number on the paper calculated by some industry analysts... whoever is involved probably made crores of rupees in bribes. but of course they did not get paid this much for the so called scam. right?
 
^ yes. as I understand, its just the amount of money the Indian Govt. could have got if those 2G spectrum was priced same as the 3G price arrived through auction.
 
so basically we are being fed bullshit by the media? i am sick and tired of listening that a raja and gang stole so much money from us (the government!). and the point remains... what's the big deal. licenses were sold for pretty cheap. 2G services have been pretty affordable for a while now. what do they want basically? charge a bounty from the operators so that they price their services high? who pays for that then? the customer. the public... high price of 3g license would mean 3g services are going to remain unaffordable for a lot of us for years. if the licenses were sold cheaply. and bandwidth is made cheap... who benefits? everyone.
 
Check this news

Tata Docomo`s 3G pricing shows that in spite of paying auction-based prices for 3G spectrum, the company has priced 3G-based voice services lower than its existing 2G voice tariff. Docomo charges a paisesec for 2G voice and has announced 3G voice at 0.66 paisesecond. Even 3G data tariffs compare favourably with 2G. Docomo`s competitive pricing ensures that other 3G operators will be compelled to price lower when they launch.

Read more: Tata's pricing of 3G dents Raja's 2G claim - The Times of India Tata's pricing of 3G dents Raja's 2G claim - The Times of India

Source

I couldn't find any link saying Tata DOCOMO is charging just 0.66p/s on 3G. Where is it given? or are they arriving at this based on bundled minutes?

---------- Post added at 03:47 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:39 PM ----------

Another reason the method of allocation is being treated as a loss to the govt is because many companies after getting startup spectrum sold their stake for huge valuations.

Swan Telecom bought a licence for 13 circles along with the necessary 2G spectrum for Rs. 1,537 crore and subsequently, it sold 45 per cent of its stake to UAE’s telecom operator Etisalat for $900 million.

Unitech, which paid Rs 1,651 crore as licence fee, has now sold 60 per cent of its stake to Norway’s Talenor for Rs. 6,120 crore, the CPM pointed out.

The deal between Etisalat and Swan Telecom, and Unitech and Talenor has brought out the magnitude of largesse that has been doled out, it said.

The government has actually got only one-sixth of what it would have got, had it gone through a fresh auction route – a loss of Rs. 10,000 crore to the exchequer on Swan and Unitech licences alone.

Link

I think this was the method that was followed even when all the incubents were given spectrum 10 or 11 years back. So what's the problem. I am trying to find the relevant link in NTP99 which says the way of allocating startup spectrum. Please post here if anyone finds it.
 
admin .. you are missing the point here. The companies which bought the spectrum sold it away to the actual telcos at market prices.So in short these intermediate companies made a lot of cash which should have been made by the government in the first place.So finally the telcos got their spectrum at the same rates which they were supposed to get.Thereby no cheap rates for the end users.SO either way the common man was never intended to get the lower rates or so in any case. Its just that the government lost a lot of moolah and thats where the problem is.
 
Back