2G Scam

  • Thread starter Thread starter Sahyadri
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 403
  • Views Views 109,040
righto. tata docomo website does not talk about costs outside the bundled minutes. so i would also assume that they are just calculating it on the basis of the bundled minutes. and we all know that they are only applicable on their own network!

also... TOI article is pretty stupid when it says: Even 3G data tariffs compare favourably with 2G.

Tata DOCOMO itself is offering 6GB data transfer for just Rs 100 on 2G (i am not sure if you can even do that much data transfer on a mobile device on Edge in India).

Their 3G prices are nowhere near these pricing!

---------- Post added at 03:57 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:54 PM ----------

well... from what i see... you cannot complain if you sell something as a wholesaler and expect to be paid the price of a retailer.

as a businessman, i would do whatever i can to generate a profit for myself. if the private companies sold their share of the spectrum for a high price, they took the right business decision!

i mean... what would you say to me if i complain... i should have bought this property 2 years ago when it was being sold for just 10 lakhs. today it is priced at 1 crores! i lost 90 lakhs. :(

they sold it at a price. the latter sold it at a higher price. that does not mean the first party made a loss and should be compensated for it! :|

---------- Post added at 03:58 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:57 PM ----------

i assume the whole scammy part is that the government did not put on a regulation that you cannot resell the spectrum for x number of years.

that makes me think that the government was sleeping when the deals were signed! was it all secretive with only a raja knowing all the details?

---------- Post added at 04:00 PM ---------- Previous post was at 03:58 PM ----------

another thing... i am not sure if airtel, vodafone, idea, reliance and others are barred from selling the 3G spectrum they paid for. supposedly... a new player arrives in the market and is willing to buy their share of the spectrum for like double the price they paid... would the government still complain that they made a 'loss' on the spectrum sale? :|
 
You said it right. When these things are happening how come no one points the fingers.Its only afterwards they start with mudslinging.It might look as something very noobish on the govt part or its a huge scam.Seriously the so called regulators are useless.
 
that is my whole problem. government (the opposition mainly) is behaving like a bitch here.

the deal was made. get over it. you cannot cry over spilled milk.

of course some people probably made a large amount of money over the whole thing. that happens in all such deals. someone probably did not get their share of the booty to stay quiet.

---------- Post added at 04:07 PM ---------- Previous post was at 04:05 PM ----------

my primary annoyance is largely with the tweets i am getting about how this guy stole so much money from the government (and hence the people of india!).

from what i see... if the spectrum was sold for cheap, it resulted in cheaper services for us. the money that goes to government does not really end up helping us (we all know what that means).

essentially, it seems to be largely connected to a group of people who did not get their share and they are just jealous of people who did. :D
 
NO you people seems to have misunderstood the problem.The question being asked is why did the telecom minister give the licenses at such low? prices. Maybe because he was paid extra under the table? I think this is the main issue.Maybe he was bribed into keeping the price down.Let the CBI complete the investigation. Until then lets remember that a person is innocent until proven guilty.
 
arey bhai...the problem is... why now? what was the opposition doing when the deals were signed! i mean... did they just realize now that spectrum can be sold at higher price. and they are not happy that the government sold it for so cheap to newer 2G players in the Indian market? i would assume here that all the aspects of the 2G spectrum sale to newer players was available publicly.from what i see, all this craziness just started after the 3G spectrum fetched the government shit load of money. more than they had expected.
 
Once they saw the amount that 3g fetched them they asked why the 2g auction hadnt bought them the same amount of money.And they realised that maybe they were shortchanged out of the 2g money so they are raising a ruckus. Also assembly elections are being held so the opposition are grasping at whatever they can lay their hands on.
 
Hehe the CBI is the most corrupt law enforcement agency in the world. As they say everything can be bought for a price. Most of the CBI investigators work under the pay of babus, if you dont think so dig up a little info

---------- Post added at 09:33 PM ---------- Previous post was at 09:14 PM ----------

To understand the scam more clearly..
FAQ's

Q1. Did he make that much money?
A. No the number 1,70,000 crores is the approximate figure of the gross revenue that the government could have potentially made out of the 2G bidding. This is basically the loss caused to the exchequer of the govt of india.

Q2. In what way am i affected?
A. Apart from the fact that you would have seen the use of 1,70,000 crores in building up of infrastructure and the likes, it has been a potential jackpot for the consumers. Since the tariff rates were low, i know that this does not affect the rates but the operators could have always quoted this is a reason and kept rates pretty high. (sigh docomo is here)

Q3. Was only A.Raja involved?
A. Initial findings and reports indicate that he was in some way indirectly or directly involved in the 2G bidding scam. He was involved with the major private players and is also accused of favouring some of the potential players by providing them with additional spectrum at cheap prices.

Q4. How does the 2G scam go about?
A. The government operates the spectrum available for communication purposes. This spectrum is auctioned to telecom players in the market. According to the TRAI regulations and recommendations - " Spectrum can only be given to those players who have some experience in this field". And only a limited number of players are allowed to bid for the spectrum. Some spectrum is always reserved for the govt PSU's like BSNL and MTNL. The scam is about why
a) Spectrum was given at lower prices and older rates.
b) Additional spectrum was given some of the players.
c) Why did A.Raja follow favouritism in awarding spectrum.
d) Why new players with no experience in this field were allowed to bid for the spectrum.
The reason this is a problem is because :

Initially the number of subscribers were very low due to the high expense of owning and operating a mobile phone. The 2G auction was held in 2008 and the rates used for auctioning the spectrum were those used in 2006. Between these 2 years the subscriber base of india had approximately grown 4x hence the profitability percent for anyone operating in this country goes up by 9700%. The main point of conflict is that how was A.Raja authorised to give the starting price of the auction and conditions as they were in 2006.

This is what the scam is about now please feel free to discuss.
 
@ admin what 1.7 lakhs crore means is the amount which was laundered in the name of A raja by gandhis outside the country probably to america in funding its wars around the world. raja was just a proxy like praful patel for gandhis.
 
Back