3G Scam?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Sushubh
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 41
  • Views Views 14,812
from what i see BWA is a type of 4G service. right?
yes , but if we had skipped 3g ; we would have a 4G network which would be much better

only because some new Indian operators had existing 3G network, they went ahead with 3G auctions which was like 3 yrs late ?

thy could have gone with 4G, 1 more yr of delay getting network deployed ; but atleast it was future proof !
 
blah. majority of mobile phones sold in the indian market are already 3G capable. 4G mobile devices are JUST beginning to launch globally. almost all the mobile service providers in the country had invested in making their networks 3G capable. it is easy to say that we should have skipped 3G and moved on to 4G. but that would have meant that all the existing devices would be incompatible with the 4G networks.
 
come back after a year and see how much of america has 4G coverage. a large part of america still does not have proper 3G coverage. and they are a developed country. india? a large part of india probably does not even have edge coverage. and you are talking about 4G in india. 3G would take its own time to spread out in the indian market.
 
If one has to stay back, he will adopt a older technology; if someone wants to catch up they will take the current technology.Replace 3G with 4G and we will be at par with US in 4-5 years.
 
India should have skipped 3G and jumped to 4G only ; we are now going to be served 3G at high cost for atleast 5-6years.

When 5G will be rolling out in other countries, our government will think about 4G spectrum.

Anyways be it 3G or 4G , our providers cant even give proper 2.5G.

Sorry, but the 3G services that are coming out simply can not be described as "high cost". Whether you compare it to current rates or to rates abroad, it's a lot cheaper than even I was expecting.

Furthermore, 4G devices just aren't common or cheap enough *right now* to really be feasible in India. 3G devices are on the market, have been for years, let's get them working properly first.

kidding right?

government made so much money from 3G spectrum. they would not have just skipped this opportunity!

anyways. LTE is also set to arrive in the indian market. not sure how that is connected to 4G and whether 4G would a different spectrum sale in the future :|

I suspect not - The BWA/LTE spectrum is basically connected to and will likely be marketed as 4G. I'm not sure why the others weren't trying to get this spectrum (near-sightedness which they'll regret in 3-4 years time??)

they would have got similar or maybe more $ for 4G bidding

2G spectrum was sold twice , so do expect 4G spectrum to be sold again in 2015/6 ?

Yeah, but look at the state of 2G spectrum now. Half the operators might have licenses cancelled in some circles.

from what i see BWA is a type of 4G service. right?

Basically. The ITU recently loosened the definition of 4G so that it looks like now the current incarnations of LTE are "acceptable".

But heck, I don't mind - the first revision of 3G 10 years ago was just 384kbit/s (I was in Japan for the launch), and now you can push up to 3.6, 7.2, 14.4 or even 21mbit/s depending on your device.

yes , but if we had skipped 3g ; we would have a 4G network which would be much better

only because some new Indian operators had existing 3G network, they went ahead with 3G auctions which was like 3 yrs late ?

thy could have gone with 4G, 1 more yr of delay getting network deployed ; but atleast it was future proof !

There are not enough devices in existance to make it feasible to skip 3G altogether - there are probably more "4G" USB dongles than "4G capable" phones.

blah. majority of mobile phones sold in the indian market are already 3G capable.

4G mobile devices are JUST beginning to launch globally.

almost all the mobile service providers in the country had invested in making their networks 3G capable.

it is easy to say that we should have skipped 3G and moved on to 4G. but that would have meant that all the existing devices would be incompatible with the 4G networks.

Yes and no. I believe like 2G phones running on 3G networks, they would just fall-back in to a compatability mode of some sort. However, since the 3G/BWA auctions have happened separately, I suspect that those running whichever version of 4G they have chosen are not allowed to run 3G-compatable and/or telephony capable networks... though that shouldn't stop anyone making a good old VOIP call.

come back after a year and see how much of america has 4G coverage.

a large part of america still does not have proper 3G coverage. and they are a developed country.

india? a large part of india probably does not even have edge coverage. and you are talking about 4G in india.

3G would take its own time to spread out in the indian market.

The US and India are quite similar in that they have large amounts of population in a few centres, and a small amount of population spread out over large areas - even if 70% of India and the 50% US is considered "rural", they're spread out enough that I suspect in some cases it's difficult enough getting ANY signal to some users, let alone high-speed.

If one has to stay back, he will adopt a older technology; if someone wants to catch up they will take the current technology.

Replace 3G with 4G and we will be at par with US in 4-5 years.

I personally hope India sets it's sights a little higher and aims to surpass the US in 4-5 years. The US is a poor yardstick for... pretty much everything.
 
Ok. I am not very smart about the whole spectrum thing. Hope you can clarify! From what I see selling of spectrum means allowing an operator to use a particular frequency of some waves. Right? How do the spectrum for 2G/3G/4G differ? Are these technologies designed to work only on a specific frequency? Or they can work on any and the government allots the one that is available at that particular moment? Can an operator that has 2G spectrum offer 3G on the same spectrum if they are allowed to do so by the government?What would happen when 4G is to be launched? Another round of spectrum sale? What exactly is LTE and BWA then? From what I see, operators today are already allowed to offer these services on the spectrum that has already been sold. BWA spectrum was sold along with 3G from what I remember. How does LTE fit into this?
 
Ok. I am not very smart about the whole spectrum thing. Hope you can clarify!

I don't guarantee my information to be 100% correct, but here's how I understand the situation.

From what I see selling of spectrum means allowing an operator to use a particular frequency of some waves. Right?

Basically, yes. In particular, frequencies that don't interfere with any other civilian or military applications within the concerned jurisdiction. And they're never purchased: only ever leased from the governing body. Periods of 20-30 years are typical.

How do the spectrum for 2G/3G/4G differ? Are these technologies designed to work only on a specific frequency? Or they can work on any and the government allots the one that is available at that particular moment?


In practicality, there are given ranges available according to the technology.

From memory 700, 850, 900, 1800, 1900 and 2100MHz are typical ranges for GSM radios of varying generations, with 900/1800/2100 being the most common worldwide for the 2G/3G combination (and thus it's no coincidence that many phones are sold as tri, quad or even penta-band capable with at least these 3 frequencies, which guarantees that they will work pretty much everywhere), instead of your phone working in some countries but not in others (Japan, South Korea, USA and Canada used to be really hard to roam to partially because of this).

The government generally determines which frequencies are most suitable for use in it's jurisdiction. Typically 900 is normal for 2G, 1800 or 2100 is normal for 3G. I don't really know why, it just is, but I think this is where the backward compatability comes in: phones with tri-band radios can fall back to 2G if they can't find a 3G signal (effectively speaking: 2 different networks, 2 different frequencies).

Can an operator that has 2G spectrum offer 3G on the same spectrum if they are allowed to do so by the government?


Yes and no.

Technically speaking there is nothing to prevent it, as equipment is on the market now to allow W-CDMA/UMTS to run at the lower frequencies (giving it a distance advantage), but I'd suggest an operator running 3G services on 2G spectrum would get their ass kicked in India.

It may happen eventually that licensees will be allowed to re-purchase or re-negotiate at some time in the future to run 3G services over their existing 2G spectrums (which may be why the 2G scam has become a huge fuss all of a sudden).

What would happen when 4G is to be launched? Another round of spectrum sale? What exactly is LTE and BWA then? From what I see, operators today are already allowed to offer these services on the spectrum that has already been sold. BWA spectrum was sold along with 3G from what I remember. How does LTE fit into this?

If I'm to understand correctly, BWA was the sale of the 700MHz and 3500MHz spectrums (which I assume is for long and short distances respectively), both frequencies of which can typically be used for 802.16e and LTE.
 
ok so to maintain compatibility globally... ranges of spectrum is reserved for specific technologies. but since 3G devices are also 2G capable... they SHOULD still be able to use 3G delivered through 2G spectrum (in the future if the rules are changed and operators are allowed!). i guess this does not mean that 2G capable devices would be able to access 3G if 3G is delivered through spectrum generally reserved for 2G? :| because some hardware is required for 3G (apart from the hardware to access that particular spectum?). hah. funny questions.
 
ok so to maintain compatibility globally... ranges of spectrum is reserved for specific technologies.

but since 3G devices are also 2G capable... they would still be able to use 3G delivered through 2G spectrum (in the future if the rules are changed and operators are allowed!).

i guess this does not mean that 2G capable devices would be able to access 3G if 3G is delivered through spectrum generally reserved for 2G? :| because some hardware is required for 3G (apart from the hardware to access that particular spectum?).

hah. funny questions.

It's a different kind of radio, so I'm guessing a UMTS radio could receive UMTS signal on whichever frequency it finds first - 3G actually reduces the battery life of your phone by a small amount. I'm not entirely sure why, but I think it may be because then the phone effectively has 2 radios operating (in case it needs to fall back or hand-over to the 2G network if 3G goes out of range or something). As for the spectrum changes, this *may* require 2G services to be turned off to prevent clashes.

Not being a device designer of course, I'm not 100% sure - it could just be the output of radio in UMTS mode has to be higher for it to work, thus consuming a few extra milliwatts.
 
Back