3G Scam?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Sushubh
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 41
  • Views Views 14,812
Hi MG ! there is a correction here. The BWA licenses sold by the government were in the 2300 MHz frequency band not in 700 & 3500 Mhz. There were 3 License in every circle with 1 reserved for Bsnl/Mtnl remaining 2 for others. About Bsnl, I am not sure whether they were provided spectrum in 2300 Mhz itself as there are some news that they are building their Wimax on the 2500 Mhz frequency, but don't the actual situation.The spectrum band in the lower frequencies 700 & other band is still to be vacated as as per my knowledge. The government is looking forward to digitalize the Tv broadcast( Doordarshan channels) completely by 2017 to empty the lower frequency bands used by them.
 
Hi MG ! there is a correction here. The BWA licenses sold by the government were in the 2300 MHz frequency band not in 700 & 3500 Mhz. There were 3 License in every circle with 1 reserved for Bsnl/Mtnl remaining 2 for others. About Bsnl, I am not sure whether they were provided spectrum in 2300 Mhz itself as there are some news that they are building their Wimax on the 2500 Mhz frequency, but don't the actual situation.

Ahh yes. Quite right. My bad.

The spectrum band in the lower frequencies 700 & other band is still to be vacated as as per my knowledge. The government is looking forward to digitalize the Tv broadcast( Doordarshan channels) completely by 2017 to empty the lower frequency bands used by them.

I think they are still mulling over 700MHz, but I had read somewhere about 3.5GHz as well which is where I must have got confused.

---------- Post added at 05:39 AM ---------- Previous post was at 05:37 AM ----------

so who won the BWA rights apart from RIL?

A combination of Qualcomm, Tikona, Aircel and Airtel.

Infotel secures pan-India BWA spectrum licence
 
Yep I believe they are looking to auction 3.5 Ghz soon may be in 1 or 2 years as they are also looking for 1900 Mhz band to be auctioned to CDMA players for EVDo sevices if the defence vacates the spectrum till the end of the coming year. I had heard possibility of round 2 of both 3G/ BWA spectrum happening soon may be in 1-1.5 year.
 
another question. what is the next upgrade for CDMA? from what i see they are already offering 3.1 mbps speeds on their networks. what's next? another stupid question. LTE, Wimax are based on GSM/CDMA or totally different things?
 
I was really surprised when bwa auction was taking place as most of the companies were not giving it more/equal value than 3G spectrum, why so! The BWA spectrum auctioned was 20 Mhz unpaired TDD spectrum while the 3G spectrum on bid was a meagre 5 Mhz of paired FDD spectrum. As most of the operators winning 3G are also seeing data as the main source of revenue instead of Video calls. While the BWA spectrum has far more capacity of data.Might be becoz they were looking to maintain their already huge 2G customer base which coul have gone to others if they hadn't secured the 3G spectrum. It would be really intresting to see when the BWA winners launch their services this year as they have obligations of covering certain %age of Towns & Disricts in the first 2 Years of spectrum holding. May be some price war waiting to be unleashed till the end of next year as there will be 7 or 8 wireless broadband providers in the market.
 
is it possible to use BWA on mobile phones? i think LTE and Wimax capable phones are already out in the US market?
 
EVDo in the next upgrade for CDMA operators. There are 3 vesions available for Evdo providers to commercially launch services.EVDO Rev. 0 - 2.4 Mbps (used by BSNl earlier for EVDO)EVDO Rev. A - 3.1 Mbps (Used by TATA,Reliance , MTS & now Bsnl also.EVDO Rev. B - 14.1 Mbps ( Reliance& Tata are looking to upgrade the top cities with this version in the next year to compete Hsdpa services provided by GSm operators.WIMAX is totally different network based on Microwave radiowaves. LTE is considered as succesor to HSPA +.Though Ultra Mobile Broadband was the upgrade to EVDO but its development has been stopped as LTE is better & it is compatible with all network types CDMA,GSM,HSDPA,HSPA+,EVDO,WIMAX. Any of these network can be upgraded to LTE directly & dongle and chipsets are available which provide seamless integration of all these network with LTE which means like when a phone doesn't find 3G it switches to 2G, same will be with LTE. Yes the LTE & Wimax can also work on mobiles. Manufacturers are working on developing more & more Mobiles chipsets which will allow mobiles to work on 2G/3G/LTE at same time.
 
Yep I believe they are looking to auction 3.5 Ghz soon may be in 1 or 2 years as they are also looking for 1900 Mhz band to be auctioned to CDMA players for EVDo sevices if the defence vacates the spectrum till the end of the coming year. I had heard possibility of round 2 of both 3G/ BWA spectrum happening soon may be in 1-1.5 year.

I thought it was a lower frequency which they were waiting for the defence services to migrate away from...

another question. what is the next upgrade for CDMA? from what i see they are already offering 3.1 mbps speeds on their networks. what's next?

another stupid question.

LTE, Wimax are based on GSM/CDMA or totally different things?

All of the above.

CDMA as far as CDMA/EV-DO is concerned is close enough to dead - Qualcomm has ceased development from what is available now and is now supporting one of the 3GPP standards. IMO, there won't be much point in "upgrading" from CDMA - perhaps for these players, a migration to Wimax of some sort is needed.

Essentially the GSM lineage goes GPRS>EDGE>3G>3.5G>LTE.

3G is a marketing term for something called W-CDMA, but just to be confusing, W-CDMA are not exactly of the same family of specifications. Maybe this table will be of help: 3G - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

I was really surprised when bwa auction was taking place as most of the companies were not giving it more/equal value than 3G spectrum, why so! The BWA spectrum auctioned was 20 Mhz unpaired TDD spectrum while the 3G spectrum on bid was a meagre 5 Mhz of paired FDD spectrum. As most of the operators winning 3G are also seeing data as the main source of revenue instead of Video calls. While the BWA spectrum has far more capacity of data.

Might be becoz they were looking to maintain their already huge 2G customer base which coul have gone to others if they hadn't secured the 3G spectrum. It would be really intresting to see when the BWA winners launch their services this year as they have obligations of covering certain %age of Towns & Disricts in the first 2 Years of spectrum holding. May be some price war waiting to be unleashed till the end of next year as there will be 7 or 8 wireless broadband providers in the market.

Basically 3G provides a seamless upgrade to a anyone owning a 3G capable phone - the customer doesn't have to buy a new device, merely switch plan, and as such adoption can be pushed far more easily.

This is not the case with 4G/LTE/WiMax.

EVDo in the next upgrade for CDMA operators. There are 3 vesions available for Evdo providers to commercially launch services.
EVDO Rev. 0 - 2.4 Mbps (used by BSNl earlier for EVDO)
EVDO Rev. A - 3.1 Mbps (Used by TATA,Reliance , MTS & now Bsnl also.
EVDO Rev. B - 14.1 Mbps ( Reliance& Tata are looking to upgrade the top cities with this version in the next year to compete Hsdpa services provided by GSm operators.

WIMAX is totally different network based on Microwave radiowaves. LTE is considered as succesor to HSPA +.
Though Ultra Mobile Broadband was the upgrade to EVDO but its development has been stopped as LTE is better & it is compatible with all network types CDMA,GSM,HSDPA,HSPA+,EVDO,WIMAX. Any of these network can be upgraded to LTE directly & dongle and chipsets are available which provide seamless integration of all these network with LTE which means like when a phone doesn't find 3G it switches to 2G, same will be with LTE.

Yes the LTE & Wimax can also work on mobiles. Manufacturers are working on developing more & more Mobiles chipsets which will allow mobiles to work on 2G/3G/LTE at same time.

Wimax also has a larger theoretical coverage area - instead of something like 15 miles, it can do something like 30, which is quite advantageous for those parties wishing to deploy mobile broadband.

It seems likely that there will be two competing options for "4G" in India: mobile broadband designed for normal use - the WiMax, and LTE for when LTE mobile phones come out - I think this would happen in a similar way to how you have EV-DO and GPRS (now also 3G) now. The two are basically not compatible with each other, so it's likely that people will pick a side and stick with it, otherwise they have to buy new hardware.
 
We have all heard about the 2G scam where the government claims that they could not make as much revenue from selling the spectrum as they could have made otherwise.

We need to talk about the 3G scam. The scam involving the government that resulted in us the consumer getting a poor deal.

All the 3G license holders are paying so much money for the spectrum that it is pretty clear that we are not going to get affordable services in the near future.

It is also needed to be made clear, what the government is planning to do with funds generated from the spectrum sale. Is it going to be used for our benefit? Or would it be wasted in the name of subsidies or other crap?

I mean, I do not really see anything positive going on. Expressways are a good example. Every single piece of decent road being laid in the country comes with a price tag. I mean, all the new expressways being opened in around Delhi NCR have a toll tax. Roads in colonies and sectors are all broken up. Prices are going high. Government keeps on crying about losses made from selling fuel at subsidized prices. Even though, half of the price of auto fuel is taxes which again go to the government. And then they claim that the oil companies are making huge losses.

What the f is going on?

may be they are going to cover the 2G loss with this 3G revenue !

Indians will become rich but india will remain as a poor country and get loans from world bank to lay roads , build schools and hospitals !
 
Back