Great Soul: Mahatma Gandhi and His Struggle With India

  • Thread starter Thread starter Deleted member 13033
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 30
  • Views Views 7,877
well it seems Lelyved is saying he took the letters and text from the national Indian archives....hmm....but I am guessing not many ppl know about or read those archives obviously so he just picked up things which he knew will cause unrest here and which also allowed him to have a free publicity for his book too !!
 
so he has proof for stuff he writes in his book. what would the indian government do! :Dburn those proofs and then claim that the book has false information?
 
Banning the book leaves an impression that we are tryinig to hide something and it looks not a mature decision. Weird decision.
 
so how does banning the book helps?
It helps to sell more books :)

Funny how ppl that dont like a book do things that ends up selling more books. Oh thats right these ppl are morons in the first place isn't it.

Complete pseudo's, gandhi does not need any protectors.

i bet the people responsible for ban on the book have not even read it.
Of course they haven't.

dude he said in his book Gandhiji left his wife becz he was interested in some man wtf does that imply even if he did not specifically use the word !!
Where does it say that ? have you read the book.

I notice you do not provide any links to the statements you make, that is bad form in a forum.

This is total BS if we allow this to happen next thing we know is then west will write any crap about us as they want.....as if what ever ppl in west thing about us from SLUMDOG millionaire wasn't enough. ! (btw plz dont start discussing about Slumdog millionaire here guys :D )
Who the F** cares what others say? Are we going to change our minds here, no. Gandhi has a much bigger legacy & meaning than some damn book or any number of books.

Everyone knows Gandhi had his own quirks, what about all those young girls he used to sleep next to, no charges of paedophilia here. why not.

Fareed Zakaria promoted the book yesterday on his GPS show saying it was a good book that explains how an ordinary individual turned into the mahatma. Why aren't we talking about that instead of all this rubbish.

This 'right to be offended' nonsense has gone on long enough !!

Govts should not be in the business of banning books, they should be concerned about how the country is being run. ppl that ask for bans do not understand and are enemies of freedom of expression !
 
It helps to sell more books :)







I notice you do not provide any links to the statements you make, that is bad form in a forum.





have you even read my 1st post before u jumped and decided post on the thread and accusing me of bad forum practices obviously you haven't ??

I have already put the text from the book which has been making the news and media and interpretations which has led to !!

here is another article..

Gandhi ‘left his wife to live with a male lover’. « Ramanan50's Blog
 
http://img96.imageshack.us/img96/3989/capturemz.png
http://img198.imageshack.us/img198/1011/54382172.png
 
have you even read my 1st post before u jumped and decided post on the thread and accusing me of bad forum practices obviously you haven't ??
And i dont see any links in your 1st post which was my point.

I have already put the text from the book which has been making the news and media and interpretations which has led to !!
Quotes must be preceded with links so everyone can see where you got it from.

Quotes alone is what you did and again, my point.

here is another article..

Gandhi ‘left his wife to live with a male lover’. « Ramanan50's Blog
Blogs refer to other sources. the source i asked for is this

Daily Mail : Gandhi 'left his wife to live with a male lover' new book claims- 28th March 2011

Got it ?
 
And i dont see any links in your 1st post which was my point.


Quotes must be preceded with links so everyone can see where you got it from.

Quotes alone is what you did and again, my point.


Blogs refer to other sources. the source i asked for is this

Daily Mail : Gandhi 'left his wife to live with a male lover' new book claims- 28th March 2011

Got it ?

dude search the thread its all there what ever you are asking for again you have not searched the thread :rofl:.....weki links are also here btw in thread were the text was taken from :D
 
What's there to feel ashamed even if the authors claims are true?Our country is proud of him because of what Good he did to our nation, no one is perfect and even if he did whatever is claimed, it doesn't mean he won't be respected in future.It's his personal life, the thing is what this author is trying to do bringing this things out?
 
Back