How secure are EVMs?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Sushubh
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 299
  • Views Views 27,381
What the use of paper trail when EC is not willing to count them and is not that possible to program EVM in that way that paper trail slip show correct slip but evm store modify results? I do not believe on paper trail.

Instead of verifying punjab election result with paper trail. EC told arvind kejriwal to introspect their defeat instead of blaming EVMs.
So, EC jobs to advice politics parties what to do or investigate allegation raised on EVMs?
 
Truth is they doesn't want to come in reality and accept that they lost. Instead of analysing their own mistake they are making accusations.

DESPERATION IS REALLLL LOL
 
i have mentioned this before. they should allow the party/candidate to pay for the counting of paper trail if they desire. as simple as that. and i believe machines are already tested in presence of representatives of candidates before voting begins to show them that the votes are being recorded properly. transparency is never a bad thing. the way EC is behaving only adds to the suspicion no matter what your political affiliation is. right to vote is one of the most important rights people have in a democracy and it's better that doubts raised by people/candidates/parties are respected and responded to.
 
recently i heard AK interview and he mentioned that 12k EVMs are going to used in Delhi MCD election and its not practical to test 12k EVMs or Is it? I believe there were thousands of EVM were used in Punjab election and checking all EVMs manually is not practical and what if person who have tamer EVMs has programmed it in a way that starting few 100s votes reflect correct and later it start its start malfunctioning? That's why many politician say that at least 100 vote should be cast to check EVM authenticity by EC. EC just press few button and give EVM clean chit. There are incident where EVMs malfunctioning caught during the vote cast by people so did not EC checked those machine before using them on booth?

@ShanksZ And there is a reason why they want to match VVPAT with election result. Because on many polls AAP just managed to get 1 or 2 vote and according to them they have dozenes of volunteer and their family members in that particular area who are ready to give affidavit that they have voted for AAP but their vote did not reflect in results. That's the reason they want EC to count VVPAT and after recent MP EVM incident. It is no doubt that EVMs can't be tamper.

There is no harm counting VVPAT if people want it. EC just behaving ignorant thugs. They still claim that EVMs are tamper proof even after they saw it with their naked eye front of media cameras.
 
yup. it's better the live in denial then to create a situation where every election result of the last decade and more could be questioned.
 
And if VVPAT are going to count then it must be happen under the surveillance of aap party otherwise they will just claim that they did not find anything wrong.

Well EC has told AAP party if they want VVPAT to count then they must have bring order from HC. Lets see if AAP approach HC for this matter.
 
they refused the request to hold election by paper ballot already right? seems unlikely they would allow for something that would open up a gigantic can of worms :D remains to be seen.
 
Nothing in this world is really a secure. Every lock has it's own key. If you have it you can open it.


Reason For not to use "paper ballot"

1) "paper ballot" is wast of time any lot's of money.
2) "paper ballot" is more risky then EVM.

How to make EVM More secure
1) Group all Contestant in order of 1-5, 6-10 and so on randomize their group position in that group and seal that EVM before 48 hour of the voting. It will discourage EVM tampering because no one knows which position he/she will get on EVM.
2) Built EVM with combination of electrical and mechanical component so both can record the count of vote with button code.

Waring for some more suggestion
 
Back