How secure are EVMs?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Sushubh
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 299
  • Views Views 27,381
@pratik_1334 1) So just to save few days and money. Is it ok to risk whole indian democracy?
2) Is that why all the developed countries(USA, Germany, France and many more) has went back to use paper ballot from EVMs? Because paper ballot is risky?

I know politician used to fraud with paper ballot too but still its way secure than EVMs because there are more chances of getting caught and also its require more effort to fraud with paper ballot and doing it on large scale such as EVMs does not seems practical.



Source
 
I don't think electronic machines are good idea, regardless of politics. Fraud might be possible in ballot paper but there can be simple physical checks to prevent it. At least VVPAT with mandatory(who will decide order, counting otherwise?) counting should be necessary but then also same steps as paper ballots need to be taken to prevent physical fraud though two stage check would be helpful. Also note that Government is not giving money to acquire vvpat EVMs.

Also think EC shouldn't give political replies, just reasons. And EC saying EVM 'tamper-proof'seems to be lie.
 
When ever someone make announcement to reveal something important related to politics. He either get disappear, sold out or become quite for some unknown reason.
 
Credibility of Electronic Voting Machines- regarding.


Some activists approached Supreme Court in 2009 which advised them to go to ECI. It was then these activists opened dialogue and ECI threw open challenge to anyone to demonstrate how machine owned by ECI can be tempered. However, in spite of opportunities given by ECI, machines opened and internal components shown, no one could demonstrate any tempering with the machine in ECI HQ. There proceedings were videographed.

In an extraordinary measure, the Commission invited those who had expressed reservations about the Electronic Voting Machine (EVM) to come and demonstrate the points made in their allegations from 3rd to 8th August 2009. Those invited included political parties, petitioners before various courts and some individuals who had been writing to the Commission on this issue. One hundred EVMs brought from ten states namely, Andhra Pradesh, Delhi, Gujarat, Karnataka, Madhya Pradesh, Maharashtra, Punjab, Rajasthan, Tamil Nadu and Uttar Pradesh, were kept at the Commission’s office in readiness for scrutiny and for any application to establish its alleged fallibility. The EVMs were offered for such demonstration in the presence of a technical experts group as well as engineers representing the EVM manufacturers, BEL and ECIL. The outcome of this exercise is that none of the persons, who were given the opportunity, could actually demonstrate any tamper ability of the ECI-EVMs. They either failed or chose not to demonstrate.

Some activists then showed on TV channel a ‘machine’ which they claimed can be manipulated. ECI countered allegation that the ‘machine’ was stolen from EVM warehouse in Mumbai, subjected to changes by activists and thus it was no longer the ‘machine’ used by ECI.

7. Technical Security of EVMs used by ECI

(a) The machine is electronically protected to prevent any tampering/manipulation. The programme (software) used in these machines is burnt into a One Time Programmable (OTP)/Masked chip so that it cannot be altered or tampered with.

lol basically ECI won't allow you to open the machine, access to source code and expect you to perform some magic trick abra ka dabra tamper ho ja

and even if any tampered machine is caught they would say machine is faulty instead of finding why that machine "malfunctioned"
 
Back