The commission said that allowing any change of the 'motherboard' or any internal circuit etc of the EVM is like saying that anyone should be permitted to manufacture a new machine and introduce newly-made EVMs in ECI system, which is implausible and irrational.
The Election Commission said it is common knowledge that changing the 'motherboard' or internal circuitry of any electronic device is like changing the whole device itself after which it is no longer the same device.
They said it is easy for an any person with basic common sense to be able to appreciate that a non-ECI EVM or an EVM with a different 'internal circuit' is simply a different machine or at best a 'look alike' of ECI EVM and hence, can never be guaranteed by ECI to give correct results.
Such a scenario is completely ruled out within the poll panel's administrative safeguards and stringent security protocols and that's why it is not proposed in the ensuing EVM challenge of the commission.
AAP's national secretary Pankaj Kr Gupta had written to Chief Election Commissioner Dr Nasim Zaidi asking him to not set any 'rules and regulations' for the hackathon.
"We strongly urge you to reconsider the terms of the EVM challenge. Please do not set any such rules and regulations and allow it to be an open hackathon where tampering of any kind can be demonstrated on the machine," the AAP had said in the memorandum.
The commission also punctured claims made by AAP MLA Saurabh Bharwdwaj in Delhi Assembly where he made a "demonstration" on how to rig an election result by tampering the motherboard of an EVM.
The Election Commission said it must be clearly understood that it is possible for anyone to make any electronic gadget which 'looks-like' ECI EVM and demonstrate any magic or tampering.
It said any look-alike machine is just a different gadget, which is manifestly designed and made to function in a tampered manner and has no relevance, incidence or bearing on the commission's EVMs.
Any person with reasonable common sense can understand that gadgets other than ECI EVMs can be programmed to perform in a pre-determined way, but it simply cannot be implied that ECI EVMs will behave in the same manner.
ECI EVMs are technically secured and function under an elaborate administrative and security protocol.