How secure are EVMs?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Sushubh
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 299
  • Views Views 27,381
EVMs. can't be hacked or I'd say the other way it might be tempered. But if they can actually do some tempering for their favours, why did they lose Punjab, didn't get full majority in Goa Manipur ect...

For me Gujarat elections were just as I was expecting.

BJP losing seats but still managing to keep majority
Congress not getting majority but gets more seats
AAP gets zero seats

I am expecting similar situation in 2019 LS elections.

BJP will lose seats and may / may not get majority but continue to be biggest party
Congress will gain some lost ground back but would be still far far away for any chance to form government.
AAP will gain more than 4 seats - mostly from Punjab and Delhi. But maximum 10-15.

BJP may come to power with coalition government.
Coalition government isn't good, we need to have 1-2 more terms as a full majority stand alone government.
 
There are hell so many video proof. Yes EVMs can be tempered for 100%. The company who produce EVMs for indian election has admitted in USA court that their machine can be hacked. [Read recently on some news website ]
 
You do not have to have a one track mind....

Who says you need to win on all seats.....

BJP is proficient in all.... Saam, Daam, Dand, Bhed.

So you might not know which card they are playing and when.

Regarding the Punjab & Delhi Municipal Election.... it was quid pro quo...... Congress got Punjab..... BJP got Delhi...... at the same time BJP/ SAD was saved in Punjab because if AAP would have come to power they would investigated Manjithia & other corruption cases.... similarly in Delhi if AAP had come in MCD they would have investigated the most corrupt municipality in the world...... So it was win win for both BJP & Congress as at the same time both of them did not want AAP to grow.....

As for Goa & Manipur.... it was regular horse trading game.......

did Congress raise the issue of EVM....... on the contrary Amarinder Singh is saying so audaciously that If EVM were hacked I would not have won Punjab Election.....
 
honestly, the best thing they can do is allow any candidate to ask for a recount. if the number matches, charge for the manpower consumed in counting. if not, accept the machine's fault and update the result.

yes, it would create massive mayhem but at least the whole issue of tempering would be shut down permanently. checking a few random machines is not very transparent. because it raises the issue that eci might specifically target evms which were not tempered with in the first place.

or maybe just allow all parties to select n number of evms and test them instead of opening it to every single candidate.
 
AAP will 1000% agree to your suggestion but BJP (also read EC) will never agree to such a suggestion...
 
And why not Ballot paper????

To put all allegations and speculations to rest...
 
because that is not going to happen. just like aadhaar would not be dismantled. so we have to aim at workarounds that provide decent protection. in either cases, there is no perfect solution so people would keep cribbing and people in power would continue to enjoy their powers.
 
You do not have to have a one track mind....

Who says you need to win on all seats.....

BJP is proficient in all.... Saam, Daam, Dand, Bhed.

So you might not know which card they are playing and when.

Regarding the Punjab & Delhi Municipal Election.... it was quid pro quo...... Congress got Punjab..... BJP got Delhi...... at the same time BJP/ SAD was saved in Punjab because if AAP would have come to power they would investigated Manjithia & other corruption cases.... similarly in Delhi if AAP had come in MCD they would have investigated the most corrupt municipality in the world...... So it was win win for both BJP & Congress as at the same time both of them did not want AAP to grow.....

As for Goa & Manipur.... it was regular horse trading game.......

did Congress raise the issue of EVM....... on the contrary Amarinder Singh is saying so audaciously that If EVM were hacked I would not have won Punjab Election.....

yes you'r point also seems solid.

about Goa & other state Jugaad govt. If Congress comes to power in 2019 won't wonder if they will form their govt. in those states, independent candidates would love to bow to power & money.

both parties are doing daytime robbery but with set rules & terms acceptable to both.
 
because that is not going to happen. just like aadhaar would not be dismantled. so we have to aim at workarounds that provide decent protection. in either cases, there is no perfect solution so people would keep cribbing and people in power would continue to enjoy their powers.
If you're crying for your privacy about Aadhaar.
what have have you been doing on Facebook & Google since last decade?
why people are so damn concerned over Aadhaar all around the internet.
Yes there may be something wrong in implementation which should be sorted out but now things came to far.
 
Back