Binayak Sen

  • Thread starter Thread starter Sushubh
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 18
  • Views Views 3,399
Are you aware that ...
About two-thirds of our laws have not been used in independent India.
About 10 per cent of them can be scrapped right away.
And most of the 10 per cent in use currently have so many obsolete and conflicting provisions that they serve far more as instruments of harassment than effective means of justice.
The oldest law in the country has been in operation for over a century and half. The one sentence 1836 Bengal District Act empowers the Bengal government to create as many zillas as it wants. The Act still exists.
As do a host of other like the Indian Post Office Act of 1885, the Indian Evidence Act of 1850 or the Indian Sarais Act of 1867. Most of them cater to a colonial and feudal socio-economic environment. And they exists side by side, mostly in complete disharmony, with the Acts passed by independent India, the Industrial Disputes Act of 1947, the Companies Act of 1956 and the Patents Act of 1970 (replacing the 1911 Act) and the Act last passed, the amended Copyright Act, 1994.
Under the Indian Sarais Act, 1867, it is a punishable offence for ‘inn-keepers’ not to offer free drinking water to passer-by. Recently, a Delhi five-star hotel was taken to court by the municipal corporation on the grounds that the hotel was not doing so.
Only about 40 per cent of our laws are in regular use. Independent India has till now found no conceivable use for the rest.
The Indian Telegraph Act, which was passed in 1885, when the concept of television obviously didn’t exist, has been invoked five times in the past three years by Doordarshan over telecast rights of cricket matches played in India. This very nearly derailed the telecast of the 1996 World cup.
In the past century and a half, the socio-economic framework of the country has undergone radical changes, but the legal structure has failed to keep pace with it.
While India badly needs efficient laws, the time spent by the law-making body on the job is unbelievably little. Parliament spends less than 0.6 per cent of a Lok Sabha day on law-making.


---------- Post added at 05:10 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:09 PM ----------

Redundant laws
Redundant laws
Redundant laws
Redundant laws

---------- Post added at 05:11 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:10 PM ----------

Redundant laws
 
This thread is for old laws, or person in question?Does anybody here support Mr. Sen?I feel if his act supported Maoist in some manner, which could have led to loss of public life or property, then he should be punished.
 
the thread about the logics being used to punish him. i have little knowledge about this man or what he has done. but the newspaper reports have been very supportive of him and the cause he has been pursuing. almost everyone seems to be saying that an old law is being misused here to punish him for something that is very questionable. :|
 
holy schmoly. they are using a law that was used by the Britishers to target freedom fighters here!
Weak case so they have to try anything they can get away with.

Have they succeded or not is the question not whether he is hero or traitor.

What difference can one doctor make in the big picture ?

I feel if his act supported Maoist in some manner, which could have led to loss of public life or property, then he should be punished.
Maoists are an insurgrency that means they cannot win at the ballot and choose the bullet. THEREFORE there is a certain degree of public support for them amongst the tribals. You will have to lock them all up too. So who is going to do that then :)

Repeat after me : Maoist is only problem in non-congress state. Solution is vote congress everywhere, one family, one party, opposition hatao :D
 
"124A. 1[ Sedition.-- Whoever by words, either spoken or written, or by signs, or by visible representation, or otherwise, brings or attempts to bring into hatred or contempt, or excites or attempts to excite disaffection towards, 2[ the Government established by law in 3[ India], a 4[ shall be punished with 5[ imprisonment for life]........................

This law is ridiculous.

Life imprisonment for creating disaffection towards the government?

http://hyperactivexs.posterous.com/sedition-law-should-india-repeal-it interesting article which argues in favor of having a sedition law.
 
The Telegraph - Calcutta (Kolkata) | Opinion | Dread of democracy

The historian Ramachandra Guha has famously described India as a fifty-fifty democracy. But even admirers of India as a functioning democracy will perhaps be forced to admit that certain events in 2010 forced the needle to move beyond fifty against democracy. Threats to democracy and democratic rights have never been as evident, and as powerful, since the dark days of the Emergency in 1975-76 as they were in the course of this year
A similar violation of democratic rights occurred when the writer, Arundhati Roy, was charged with sedition under Section 124(A) of the Indian Penal Code. She is supposed to have voiced “anti-India” sentiments. There can be little doubt that many find the views of Ms Roy distasteful and perplexing. But surely, if India is a democracy, she should have the full right to express her views, however inimical those views might be to the Indian State. What is problematic is the very idea of “anti-India” sentiments. What are pro-India sentiments? Only those views and feelings approved of by the Indian State? A democracy, by definition, must have room for dissent, for argument and for difference. Dissent is part of the Indian intellectual tradition. The statement of the Union law minister that freedom of speech “cannot violate patriotic sentiments” makes a mockery of democracy and of one of the most important rights in a democracy — of free speech.


India, in 2010, has come perilously close to being a country where the mind is no longer without fear. The Indian State does not hesitate to suppress thought and opinion. There are millions of Indians who, because they are deprived of food, drinking water, healthcare and education, cannot hold their head high. A handful of people might be happy that India has a 9 per cent growth rate, but for all Indians with a conscience and a commitment to democracy, 2010 was not a year in which they could be proud to call themselves Indians. There are very good reasons to believe that Rabindranath Tagore, Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi, Jawaharlal Nehru and others like them would have shared the shame if they were alive.


we are moving towards a covert emergency era.
 
A similar violation of democratic rights occurred when the writer, Arundhati Roy, was charged with sedition under Section 124(A) of the Indian Penal Code. She is supposed to have voiced “anti-India” sentiments.
Hmm, i'm not sure she was actually charged with sedition, though there was talk about it.

A democracy, by definition, must have room for dissent, for argument and for difference.
Concur

we are moving towards a covert emergency era.
Not quite yet :)
 
Repeat after me : Maoist is only problem in non-congress state. Solution is vote congress everywhere, one family, one party, opposition hatao :D
I hope your joking. The naxals peaked at a time when bjp and nda was almost non-existent. The bjp came to power in the mid 90's through states like gujarat and maharashtra. The naxal corridor has been under non-nda rule for a good 20 years now. It is just recent that nda parties have started ruling these states. Still, with a centre run by congress, the nda states cannot do much. No co-ordination.
 
Back