I currently have both Airtel and Vodafone. I am paying 255 for 1GB 4G on Airtel + 165 for 400 minutes calling on Vodafone postpaid. So in total ~400 for 1GB + 400 mins calling and it would seem I am a good candidate for 499 plan. But I will still not opt for Jio as primary number because:
1. Setup time: I can get Airtel and Vodafone sim and be set to use 4G in couple of hours. In comparison Jio seems to have improved not one bit since May. Retailers still have the "network is down" while uploading docs. And it takes nearly a day, sometimes even 7 days, to actually be up and running.
2. Call quality: Jio to Jio voice call is awesome in quality. Jio to Jio video call was awesome in quality, no stuttering or freezes but since last month it has gone down hill. And the issue with Jio to other operators is well known. One can blame Airtel, Vodafone etc for this but this is a Jio service issue. They need to find a way to get those interconnect points.
3. Data: I have broadband at home and wifi at office, so mostly 1GB is enough for me. What Jio added for me was data on the go. I was able to enjoy YT, movies or
tv streaming. But given Jio's promise was data revolution it doesn't exactly do that with 4GB for 499. But the speeds have gone down each time they have added new users and am frankly not hopeful to get good speeds going forward.
4. Network - Since I bought the phone back in May, there has been rather miniscule improvement in Jio's overall network. Previously the indoor coverage was atrocious at best but with 850Mhz things have improved a bit. But still there are days like today where calling works but the data is down for some explicable reason. I can't seem to login to MyJio app too. In comparison, Airtel and Vodafone combined offer me lot of overlaps and coverage.
while many of my friends are excited by the plans they have been put off by "up to 7 days" activation. And if they don't get the sim I would want to use a primary sim with a call ratio of 10% - 1 call per 10 tries. Data for me has rather all over the map - sometimes really awesome and then sometime, like today, absolutely useless. Speeds indoors, on 850 Mhz has been near 2-3 Mbps. Much slower than Airtel 3G (8 Mbps) and Vodafone (16 Mbps). This in spite of multiple complains and "we are working on it" from Jio.