I have reproduced my complaint to the AIRTEL nodal officer at Chennai below:
Dear Sir,
While I started developing a feeling that Airtel is by far the best in the field of providing broadband service in India, a recent action by Airtel comes as a rude shock, spoiling the image.
I am a subscriber of your 256 kbps UL plan @ Rs.799/- p.m., which I am using for the past 8 months.
When I contacted Customercare yesterday (13-02-09) to enquire whether there was any problem with the gateway as my connection speed had suddenly fallen to 50%, I was shocked to learn that my connection speed has been cut to 128 kbps deliberately by Airtel, as my usage in the current billing period has exceeded 15 GB.
This bombshell decision gives rise to the following legal and moral issues:
1. The CC representative claimed that the action was taken due to some TRAI directive. That is a clear lie, as TRAI has NOT issued any such directive till date. It is only that Airtel has sent recently a suggestion to TRAI for introducing a "Fair Usage Policy", but it is a bllatant illegality to just go ahead and implement its suggestion without receiving an approval from TRAI. Please note even TRAI is only an advisory body and even it cannot implement a decision of this sort without
DoT approval.
2. TRAI has prescribed the lower speed limit for broadband in India as 256 kbps (though anything less than 1Mbps is not truly broadband by International standards!). So, my internet speed which has been cut to 128 kbps since 14-02-2009 is no more a broadband connection. AIRTEL is guilty of breach of contract here and is liable for legal action against.
3. There is no point in taking umbrage under a claim that ISP's in some other advanced countries have also started "capping" their unlimited plans. The internet speeds in those countries are not already curtailed to a beggarly 256 kbps! Nobody else in the world calls 256 kbps as "broad"band and it is a shame on the part of AIRTEL to decelerate it still further and call it and charge it as a broadband connection.
4. If AIRTEL wanted to implement any such modification to the existing plans they must have been honest enough to have informed the existing customers about this decision, giving an option and notice period to continue or quit, and implement the revised policy only on the expiry of the notice period. So, implementing such a decision straightaway, that too, within days of merely sending a suggestion to TRAI, is tantamount to outright CHEATING and BACKSTABBING customers who cannot accept it meekly.
5. Maybe, AIRTEL is hard pressed to save on bandwidth to divert for their newly introduced Digital
TV euphoria, but this type of armtwisting the existing customers is nothing but fraud and crass commercialisation, unbecoming of any decent
business house.
Is AIRTEL going to relent, with an apology to affected cusrtomers, or, are they going ahead with their unholy decision which is nothing but an immoral and illegal action, by any standard?
C. Lakshminarayanan
A disillusioned and disappointed customer