MTNL has an interesting deployment - at least in Mumbai (I don't know enough about their Delhi operations to say if they're the same or not).
In Mumbai, while the MTNL *exchange* can be relatively far away from the customer premises, the phone line itself is actually supplied by a roadside cabinet, which in turn is usually supplied by fibre. Those cabinets typically supply around 650 residences and are "strategically placed" to keep the copper loop as short as possible. Irrespective of whether you have problems with your line (frequent disconnections,
noise, whatever) if your line synchronizes at either >6 or >16 mbit/s (depending on whether they have ADSL1 or
ADSL2+ equipment installed) then chances are you're being supplied by some nearby cabinet rather than the exchange itself. Of course, with MTNL it can be hard to tell, since they often rate-limit the line itself rather than doing things intelligently, but sometimes they don't (especially if you're an IPTV customer).
Probably it's not the fibre that's crap, it'll most likely be the copper - if it was the fibre, then whenever you experience a problem, so would 600+ other subscribers (all at the same time) but again, with them it's very much a situation of "who the hell knows what's going on".
Thats the way they manage in delhi too. The exchange incharge told me that in our area wire have lived out the life and are more or less obsolete so providing basic phone is only option and BB is too difficult. Actually there is a new shopping complex in neighbourhood and MTNL was looking for space in that complex to setup their exchange but that complex has been constructed and lingering in some legal battle.
Because open networks are few and far between, the large players tend to prefer to lay their own cables all over the place, that's why when you're walking along the footpath you see those big concrete slabs with like "BHARTI OFC 2007" or "TTSL 2009" and so on every few hundred metres.
The problem that Bharti is facing with connecting to your society is probably the condition of the ducting (it's full of shhhhhtuff, which is a sign that whoever laid those ducts did a shoddy job, since they're supposed to be all waterproof and rodent proof and so on), and that the best option is probably for someone to come through, rip it all out and lay it again.
Preferably this would be undertaken by someone who is building an open network, so that there is just the single set of cables going in to the society and any ISP can come and provide their services on those cables without having to check for feasibility or installing more cables or whatever... all that needs to be done is to plug the right cable from the right ISP in to the right port inside some cabinet somewhere, and if the subscriber wants to change ISPs it's about a 90 second job for the technician.
We also have a open network in our society but the problem of wire getting damaged started when airtel were allowed to provided the BB services. For each flat there are 4 lines of which one is occupied by intercom rest are for the ISPs but these illiterate airtel techs ruined the entire wiring to just to get there customer satisfied and leaving others at dismay.
Awesome. If that can be confirmed then it's very probable that we would put your area on priority for deployment when we're ready to hit NCR.
If possible i would show you the area i am talking about on
Google maps. There are about 60-70 societies and about 15000 flats. This area have very high BB literacy rate so you would be in great
business here and as i told you its marked as NOIDA planned by you and is about 500M from noida.
The problem you may face is that Airtel has its customers loyal towards the firm so you have to play the dirty game of telling customers what airtel actually providing and robbing them