The Bush administration railroaded the plan through Congress. Given all that hullabaloo over WMDs, Saddam's previous history (he did use chemical weapons against Iran in the I-I war) and cooked up reports linking him to AQ, I don't think too many people could have afforded to oppose the war, given that it was just over a year since 911. So both sides supporting the war does not say much about the intent or reasons.
Pretexts given to the public who were not privvy to intelligence shared amongst congress members as well as friendly foreign intelligence.
There was also defnitely, at the time, a tendency to be painted anti-patriotic, if you voted against but there were dissenters.
Pre-emption is an interesting idea. But I think it is going to come back to bite the countries that engage in such activities. There is no way Turkey will give away its Kurd provinces to a Kurdistan. So Turkey's 'limited' war is fine by me. The strategic value of the Israel-Lebanon conflict to Israel is doubtful for I don't understand what it gained from the same. How much damage did Hezbollah really suffer? I think Israel lost face in the operation for most countries sympathised with Lebanon. It was a case of a bully throwing around his weight. But these two cases cannot be compared to the US invasion of Iraq. I don't think there is any parallel to that in modern history (considering just the 'good' guys).
Sure, in terms of what was achieved it was stalemate of sorts in Lebanon but i guess the message was clear. Israel got some bad PR for 'collateral damage' but i think the rockets stopped coming over as frequently as before. That I think was the main objective. They know the range of the ones used and only went a little beyond, any rockets coming over now would have to be with foreign aid and there is only one source for that, Iran.
If the countries being attacked are indeed 'rogue' states, and their military strength lies only in conventional weapons, then maybe it will deter a possible future misadventure (except KJI of North Korea. That idiot has so many ballistic missiles that he will sink the Korean Peninsula before giving up. So the US keeps quiet).
KJI has been quiet too, something is defnitely cooking behind the scenes.
But in today's world, threats from non-state actors is more of a reality than from any rogue nation. That said, it would be interesting to see the US reaction if Russia or China try the same thing.
Russia is completely surrounded, in Europe by NATO now, no place to go. They have been making some sound about their right to part of the Arctic Ocean but they would not be the only ones there. Also they have plenty of Oil & gas.
China will always have its eye on Taiwan, but it will be some time still until they go for it, i think the US would have to be significantly weakened before this became feasible. They won't be able to cite nat security as a pretext, it would be hard to dress up a brazen re-unification attempt.
It's possible if something develops abroad where they have several interests at the moment like Africa. A decade or two from now they will have major oil companies across the globe with large investments already.
Things are going to get even more messy, if the past few years are any thing to go by. As for the future, one thing is certain - the US is going to have to pull out of Iraq with its tail between its legs because the situation is unsalvageable. Will also happen with Afghanistan. And it will be Obama who will in all probability have to clean up the mess, like LJ did after Vietnam. The only good thing is, they have experience in these matters.
Hmm, Obama, i think will not be too different from the rest as far as nat security is concerned, he seemed even more gung ho about going to Pakistan than the rest. Its looking like he might win the nomination. But is he enough to get into the white house....hmm..for some reason i think McCain will be able to outdo him in any debate and ppl might scream about Obama but who they vote for when it comes down to it might be different. Both are also 'only' senators, neither has been governor, which one would have thought is a step necessary before doing it nationally. Does not preclude having a VP that is one tho.
There's talk that the Democrats might rope in Gore at the last minute to run and take Obama with him as VP. Gore is a Nobel winner, has been VP, almost won (some would say did win) in 2000. But that's water cooler talk
I don't believe the US will cut & run, regardless of what the dems say, to do so would mean admission that the invasion was wrong and would be counter-productive to the goals setout. The big diff to Vietnam is the opposition isn't really supported by any major power, so the resistance can only keep at it significantly for so long. They will scale back when they see improvements on the ground and that has to come sooner or later. And will prolly get a base or two setup like in Turkey, Germany or Japan.
Afghanistan is less clear, a lot depends on the central Asian republics that are all energy rich. That will always be the draw to those areas and if you have a garrision stationed in the vicinty, it makes it easier to deal with any disturbances that come along not to mention, the early stages at countering SCO at the same time.
So same thing here too, withdraw forces gradually, but the Taliban would have to be decisively defeated until that happens, whether that will ever happen remains to be seen.