Why Iraq ?

  • Thread starter Thread starter blr_p
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies Replies 18
  • Views Views 2,960

blr_p

Regulars
Messages
3,886
Location
NA
ISP
Airtel 256k ultd
I thought i knew the reason(s) but looking at the usual suspects, none of them ever held any weight and always felt a little too trivial or obvious for such a major action, till i found this

It reads quite coherently and makes sense with what i've read over the years. That poster seems to have a little edge in the credibility dept. over most bloggers or dare i say journalists.

..that is of course, if you agree that, pre-emptive strikes can be justified ?

Taken to the simplest level, if a person is injured or worse because they pose a lethal threat, can the act of stopping them be justified ?

Self-defense is valid here in most cases.

But when the 'what' & 'which' self being defended is a bit nebulous, its becomes less clear.
 
An interesting view. So oil, uprooting a barbaric dictator, a WMD threat and now a pre-emptive occupation of the Middle East as a safeguard against fundamentalists taking over the region and joining hands with Iran. Again, interesting.

Pre-emption is a hard nut to crack at a moral level. Take an analogy. A rabid dog is roaming the streets near a school. It has not attacked anyone yet. But it might very well do so. What do municipal authorities do? They immediately kill it. But humans are not dogs. And using pre-emption against them requires more thought than in the former case.

In the case of Iraq, if the war was a pre-emptive one, consider what, according to JAD_333, was the US trying to pre-empt - a loss of control over vital interests (assured supplies of oil from Saudi and Kuwait), and the danger to the existence of the state of Israel. Did it succeed? Seems to be doing so. At a HUGE cost. The question, however, is, if Saddam had been left alone to brutalize his people, where would the fundamentalists have come around from? Would the former 4th(?) largest standing army in the world keep quiet if such a thing happened within Iraq itself? As for the other countries in the region, the US was already present in a few of them one way or the other? So, I don't get the logic behind this pre-emption idea. The only thing the war seems to have done is created more problems than it could have hoped to solve.

Coming back to the idea of pre-emption itself, it is nothing but a sophisticated version of 'offence is the best defence'. But it depends on the question what are you trying to defend? If pre-emption dictates that every latent threat will be neutralized, the world is going to be a very nasty place. Self defence is an acceptable defence in the court of law. But there is a precondition. The force used should not be unreasonable. That is, you cannot kill a man attacking you or your property but who does not pose a threat to your life, and then plead self defence.

Personally, if there is a very high certainty that someone is going to do tremendous harm, and past history points in this direction, the first thing to do is immobilize him without killing him. If that is not possible, then killing him is the only alternative left. But if you have made a mistake and he turns out to be innocent....
 
In the case of Iraq, if the war was a pre-emptive one, consider what, according to JAD_333, was the US trying to pre-empt - a loss of control over vital interests (assured supplies of oil from Saudi and Kuwait), and the danger to the existence of the state of Israel. Did it succeed? Seems to be doing so. At a HUGE cost. The question, however, is, if Saddam had been left alone to brutalize his people, where would the fundamentalists have come around from? Would the former 4th(?) largest standing army in the world keep quiet if such a thing happened within Iraq itself? As for the other countries in the region, the US was already present in a few of them one way or the other? So, I don't get the logic behind this pre-emption idea. The only thing the war seems to have done is created more problems than it could have hoped to solve.


This appears to be the prevaling wisdom at the moment.

After all was said and done, was it worth it ?

jury is still out on that atm, expect things to calm down as we approach Nov

Then again they believe they can make a positive change to the neighbourhood, the idea of democracy somehow magically taking hold in a region that has known anything but, seemed enticing at the outset.

For $3trillion + another $3 trillion from the rest of the world, it better damn well be.
 
...China is financing America's war...

Excellent article. Proves that governments worldwide are in the hands of people who have less intelligence than half a snail.
 
Some more insights..

In international relationships there is very little space for logic and none for morality. It is merely interests that have to be projected, protected and enhanced.
 
While true, that is a very strange thing to say. The morality part, I can understand, for you cannot beat guile by behaving in a straightforward manner (crooked men have to be dealt with by crooked means, Kautilya says). But without logic, there is no way things can be understood and justified. Perhaps that is why we keep having these 'this is so illogical' discussions; perhaps they are really illogical. Ockham's razor - the simplest explanation is almost always the right one.
 
From what i can gather from that thread and similar ones, is that, the logic part was very clearly understood by the small circle of ppl who planned the entire operation ie the ones that 'needed to know'. But given that a lot of that thinking is semi-classified ( i can't seem to find any source substantiating any of the claims from ppl i linked to), vs. various other, more accessible theories, vying to fill in the gaps, confounded things a bit earlier. Small wonder, Bush & Blair were urging ppl to 'trust' them on this ;).AFAICT there was and still is, no doubt, by the ppl who engaged in this operation and their supporters, at all, given the majority vote in congress, at the time, in favour of the war, votes coming from both parties.I'm tempted to classify the whole operation as one of those pre-emptive moves taken by a govt. to secure its national interests. No doubt this will encourage others to do the same when they perceive the same and are capable to do so, see Turkey in Iraq recently or Israel in Lebanon.No doubt these 3 countries would argue adamantly, their actions were, despite appearances, defensive in spirit. The American one being just a more drawn out version of the other two.I'm not sure if there have been precedents of pre-emptive actions in history or whether its a new development and what it spells for future world stability. I'm inclined to think that if countries show resolve in these actions, that the result would be to deter would-be agressors, thereby justifying the action.Which then leads to the question of whether the perceived threat was real or not ?At the time, those in charge made do with what ever 'actionable' intel they had, with hindsight its always possible to fault the course of action.
 
The Bush administration railroaded the plan through Congress. Given all that hullabaloo over WMDs, Saddam's previous history (he did use chemical weapons against Iran in the I-I war) and cooked up reports linking him to AQ, I don't think too many people could have afforded to oppose the war, given that it was just over a year since 911. So both sides supporting the war does not say much about the intent or reasons.Pre-emption is an interesting idea. But I think it is going to come back to bite the countries that engage in such activities. There is no way Turkey will give away its Kurd provinces to a Kurdistan. So Turkey's 'limited' war is fine by me. The strategic value of the Israel-Lebanon conflict to Israel is doubtful for I don't understand what it gained from the same. How much damage did Hezbollah really suffer? I think Israel lost face in the operation for most countries sympathised with Lebanon. It was a case of a bully throwing around his weight. But these two cases cannot be compared to the US invasion of Iraq. I don't think there is any parallel to that in modern history (considering just the 'good' guys).If the countries being attacked are indeed 'rogue' states, and their military strength lies only in conventional weapons, then maybe it will deter a possible future misadventure (except KJI of North Korea. That idiot has so many ballistic missiles that he will sink the Korean Peninsula before giving up. So the US keeps quiet). But in today's world, threats from non-state actors is more of a reality than from any rogue nation. That said, it would be interesting to see the US reaction if Russia or China try the same thing.Things are going to get even more messy, if the past few years are any thing to go by. As for the future, one thing is certain - the US is going to have to pull out of Iraq with its tail between its legs because the situation is unsalvageable. Will also happen with Afghanistan. And it will be Obama who will in all probability have to clean up the mess, like LJ did after Vietnam. The only good thing is, they have experience in these matters.
 
The Bush administration railroaded the plan through Congress. Given all that hullabaloo over WMDs, Saddam's previous history (he did use chemical weapons against Iran in the I-I war) and cooked up reports linking him to AQ, I don't think too many people could have afforded to oppose the war, given that it was just over a year since 911. So both sides supporting the war does not say much about the intent or reasons.

Pretexts given to the public who were not privvy to intelligence shared amongst congress members as well as friendly foreign intelligence.

There was also defnitely, at the time, a tendency to be painted anti-patriotic, if you voted against but there were dissenters.


Pre-emption is an interesting idea. But I think it is going to come back to bite the countries that engage in such activities. There is no way Turkey will give away its Kurd provinces to a Kurdistan. So Turkey's 'limited' war is fine by me. The strategic value of the Israel-Lebanon conflict to Israel is doubtful for I don't understand what it gained from the same. How much damage did Hezbollah really suffer? I think Israel lost face in the operation for most countries sympathised with Lebanon. It was a case of a bully throwing around his weight. But these two cases cannot be compared to the US invasion of Iraq. I don't think there is any parallel to that in modern history (considering just the 'good' guys).

Sure, in terms of what was achieved it was stalemate of sorts in Lebanon but i guess the message was clear. Israel got some bad PR for 'collateral damage' but i think the rockets stopped coming over as frequently as before. That I think was the main objective. They know the range of the ones used and only went a little beyond, any rockets coming over now would have to be with foreign aid and there is only one source for that, Iran.

If the countries being attacked are indeed 'rogue' states, and their military strength lies only in conventional weapons, then maybe it will deter a possible future misadventure (except KJI of North Korea. That idiot has so many ballistic missiles that he will sink the Korean Peninsula before giving up. So the US keeps quiet).

KJI has been quiet too, something is defnitely cooking behind the scenes.


But in today's world, threats from non-state actors is more of a reality than from any rogue nation. That said, it would be interesting to see the US reaction if Russia or China try the same thing.

Russia is completely surrounded, in Europe by NATO now, no place to go. They have been making some sound about their right to part of the Arctic Ocean but they would not be the only ones there. Also they have plenty of Oil & gas.

China will always have its eye on Taiwan, but it will be some time still until they go for it, i think the US would have to be significantly weakened before this became feasible. They won't be able to cite nat security as a pretext, it would be hard to dress up a brazen re-unification attempt.

It's possible if something develops abroad where they have several interests at the moment like Africa. A decade or two from now they will have major oil companies across the globe with large investments already.


Things are going to get even more messy, if the past few years are any thing to go by. As for the future, one thing is certain - the US is going to have to pull out of Iraq with its tail between its legs because the situation is unsalvageable. Will also happen with Afghanistan. And it will be Obama who will in all probability have to clean up the mess, like LJ did after Vietnam. The only good thing is, they have experience in these matters.

Hmm, Obama, i think will not be too different from the rest as far as nat security is concerned, he seemed even more gung ho about going to Pakistan than the rest. Its looking like he might win the nomination. But is he enough to get into the white house....hmm..for some reason i think McCain will be able to outdo him in any debate and ppl might scream about Obama but who they vote for when it comes down to it might be different. Both are also 'only' senators, neither has been governor, which one would have thought is a step necessary before doing it nationally. Does not preclude having a VP that is one tho.

There's talk that the Democrats might rope in Gore at the last minute to run and take Obama with him as VP. Gore is a Nobel winner, has been VP, almost won (some would say did win) in 2000. But that's water cooler talk :D

I don't believe the US will cut & run, regardless of what the dems say, to do so would mean admission that the invasion was wrong and would be counter-productive to the goals setout. The big diff to Vietnam is the opposition isn't really supported by any major power, so the resistance can only keep at it significantly for so long. They will scale back when they see improvements on the ground and that has to come sooner or later. And will prolly get a base or two setup like in Turkey, Germany or Japan.

Afghanistan is less clear, a lot depends on the central Asian republics that are all energy rich. That will always be the draw to those areas and if you have a garrision stationed in the vicinty, it makes it easier to deal with any disturbances that come along not to mention, the early stages at countering SCO at the same time.

So same thing here too, withdraw forces gradually, but the Taliban would have to be decisively defeated until that happens, whether that will ever happen remains to be seen.
 
Hmm, Obama, i think will not be too different from the rest as far as nat security is concerned, he seemed even more gung ho about going to Pakistan than the rest. Its looking like he might win the nomination. But is he enough to get into the white house....hmm..for some reason i think McCain will be able to outdo him in any debate and ppl might scream about Obama but who they vote for when it comes down to it might be different. Both are also 'only' senators, neither has been governor, which one would have thought is a step necessary before doing it nationally. Does not preclude having a VP that is one tho.

There's talk that the Democrats might rope in Gore at the last minute to run and take Obama with him as VP. Gore is a Nobel winner, has been VP, almost won (some would say did win) in 2000. But that's water cooler talk :D

I am not too sure of Gore entering the picture since he has denied the possibility too many times. And would the DP dare to supersede the 'will' of the people? John Kerry, was talking on CNN, and he said that the super delegates would more or less side with whoever has the most pledge delegates. Don't know the exact workings or figures, but am pretty sure that that (sic) is Obama. In any case, will know for sure in about 24 hours time. So, how can you suddenly bring in a third candidate after all that has been done to narrow down the list? As you say, it is most probably water cooler gossip.

McCain might be a POW/ war hero type. But I have been hearing too much about how it is the possibility of a recession that is really spooking the American public. Don't know what McCain has to say on that front, but 12-16 years of Republican rule is nothing short of a nightmare. If they don't shoot themselves in the foot as they seem to do all the time, I think it is the DP which will move into the White House come Jan 2009.

I don't believe the US will cut & run, regardless of what the dems say, to do so would mean admission that the invasion was wrong and would be counter-productive to the goals setout. The big diff to Vietnam is the opposition isn't really supported by any major power, so the resistance can only keep at it significantly for so long. They will scale back when they see improvements on the ground and that has to come sooner or later. And will prolly get a base or two setup like in Turkey, Germany or Japan.

Afghanistan is less clear, a lot depends on the central Asian republics that are all energy rich. That will always be the draw to those areas and if you have a garrision stationed in the vicinty, it makes it easier to deal with any disturbances that come along not to mention, the early stages at countering SCO at the same time.

So same thing here too, withdraw forces gradually, but the Taliban would have to be decisively defeated until that happens, whether that will ever happen remains to be seen.
From where I stand, Iraq and Afghanistan are looking more like Vietnam than anything else - weak governments, heavy casualties, and guerilla warfare. Agreed the casualties are not comparable. But things do look eerily similar. In any case, I think it was the body bags that made the US turn back than the possibility of having to face China-Russia. Dealing with insurgency is a supreme pita as we know. They got themselves embroiled in this bad awful situation. Let them find a way out.

Russia is completely surrounded, in Europe by NATO now, no place to go. They have been making some sound about their right to part of the Arctic Ocean but they would not be the only ones there. Also they have plenty of Oil & gas.

China will always have its eye on Taiwan, but it will be some time still until they go for it, i think the US would have to be significantly weakened before this became feasible. They won't be able to cite nat security as a pretext, it would be hard to dress up a brazen re-unification attempt.

It's possible if something develops abroad where they have several interests at the moment like Africa. A decade or two from now they will have major oil companies across the globe with large investments already.

The Russia farce of an election is now complete and no surprises there. The thing is, I have seen a couple of news reports and the economic situation there does not seem to be all that hunky dory. There seems to be some kind of inflation going on with prices rising through the roof. And its the people in the smaller cities that are bearing the brunt. Where is all the oil revenue going? Into Putin's pockets? Maybe that is why he is doing all the sabre rattling, coz he is kind of losing control over the situation. Another funny thing - Russia's support for sanctions against Iran. What are they trying to do? Being pliable, or trying to bring down a big competitor in the oil business.

I am in two minds about China. An entire generation has now been part of the consumer culture. Think they will give everything away just like that for Taiwan, or a conflict far away from their shores? The next logical step is some kind of democracy. Maybe an experiment at first and then a gradual shift. Coz there is no way the Chinese are going back to a hardcore communist past.
 
Back